|
This is why we should never trust the town circles -_-
It's interesting though, why he would choose to reveal it. If he is red there was absolutely no reason for him to make the fact public since mafia knows his identity anyway. There is no gain- unless he wants to incriminate foolishness along with him by exploiting his foolish lack of secrecy. So if he flips scum I will be slightly inclined to believe him as town.
If he is green facepalm to me for not thinking to remove cancer of the town when I had the opportunity yesterday.
|
WTF DOUBLE POST
Actually, if BM actually flips green, then it is time to put pressure on foolishness, because frankly he should know better. I also wouldn't put much credence into position people took regarding certain person; I saw way much examples where player dogmatically and irrationally defended someone while being town. It by itself is not enough to incriminate someone, and should be only used as indicator - "oh he defended scum better iso him" instead of "omg he defended scum lynch him!"
|
This is all WIFOM.
BrownBear and Foolishness are in contact with each other. Foolishness is also in separate contact with Bill Murray. If Foolishness is mafia, then he can kill BB with impunity, but BB might have taken insurance by telling someone about contact between them. So by telling Bill Murray, he buys an way out because he was under big pressure yesterday- and knowing his play tendency might have expected him to reveal it. The fact supporting this argument is that I see no reason for Foolishness to tell Bill Murray BB's role.
Of course I think other way is more probable, that Bill Murray is scum and he is taking advantage of Foolishness's mistake by revealing the fact that he came to knew BB's identity due to Foolishness. Knowing how Foolishness defended him, it would not be very hard to push for his lynch if BM flips red. Fact supporting this is I see no reason why Bill Murray would reveal he know BB's role- I honestly do not believe Bill thought revealing someone else's role was going to save him.
|
The reason why I like BM scum theory is that Foolishness scum one feels kind of a stretch. I think it is just as equally as probable that he was incautious with his knowledge. God knows PM land is some sort of crazy drug in TL Mafia which either cause insanity or brilliance in players.
|
I was giving my thoughts on just what happened. Think it would be pretty terrible to polarize your opinion on others just because he was "BM supporter", "youngminii supporter". That's not healthy at all as we do have lot of people with headstrong opinions as well.
If Bill Murray flips red, I am going to read through Foolisness's posts deep and hard before I make a decision to lynch him as another scum.
|
Wait, if all (I suppose so because you say both and I don't see more than two trackers) Trackers visited you wtf didn't you tell this to the town? There are possibility of Godfather, but to knowledge people randomly nominated you (I think LSB did who turned out to be town) so possibility itself was slim, right?
|
My Idea: I don't like the idea of sending out one's role over PM, but barring small possibility that he is Godfather, both Tracker tracking him sounds legit. So I think any PR should definitely wait for two hours or so in order to give chance for trackers to read the post before claiming. If there are no cc to Xelin's claim, I suppose it is safe to form circle around him...
|
You used tracker's' contacted you, and I don't see Flamewheel putting more than 2 in since they are investigation role. I just don't. I suppose I'll wait and see- read my post above.
|
That's why I never make or join PM setups, obviously this was a terrible exception. Also, I think I've asked this question before, but was there ever scenario in where the role specified in the OP did not exist in normal TL Mafia setups? Because I don't think there are, meaning there should be Watcher.
|
I'll wait and see. Enough votes have been traded places to make a difference anyway.
|
*Sigh* I knew it. Want to say if the PR role organization doesn't out anyone by tomorrow, I am going to push lynch for Bill Murray though. Switching vote to youngminii.
|
I just merely pondered the possibility of him being an *****
|
My God, Xelin you are such... astounding organizers, along with who the hell is in your party,
|
Watch Pandain flip green vanilla (only gut speaking here).
|
What can you do, he has the power. Hopefully the pure mechanics of PR organization pulls through.
|
Lawl only the cruel person will hit Divinek and ~OpZ~ tonight it seems >.<
|
On August 12 2010 11:31 rastaban wrote: I was role blocked last night guys
|
On August 12 2010 23:27 bumatlarge wrote: I cant really put my finger on the BM and Foolishness arguement, but I guess Im in no place to talk since i "didnt roleclaim"
Im going to put my vote on xelin until he rectifies this. Why? The framer is dead and no blue roles were sniped.
|
I am waiting for Xelin group to propose their lynch target & suspects. I'll try to give my opinion about it when they do so.
|
On August 14 2010 01:50 bumatlarge wrote: And if my posts lack humor, blame the penalty game. FUCKHSHFURHSPQ.
I will now not mention that ever again. Oh boy, do I have an epic post-game note for you guys being prepared right now.
|
|
|
|