Players that should be on the list or placed higher: Silver,Goodfriend,Iloveoov and maybe a #5-6 for Nal_ra.
I agree with the rest of the list,its just my opinion.
Forum Index > Polls & Liquibet |
Coulthard
Greece3359 Posts
Players that should be on the list or placed higher: Silver,Goodfriend,Iloveoov and maybe a #5-6 for Nal_ra. I agree with the rest of the list,its just my opinion. | ||
Hot_Bid
Braavos36362 Posts
| ||
omgbnetsux
United States3749 Posts
On December 01 2006 14:57 Hot_Bid wrote: after watching superfight im going to have to say i disagree with your #1, savior should not be up on the list at all I agree. It is obvious that Oov should be #1. | ||
Sewi
Germany1697 Posts
| ||
TehKris
Norway322 Posts
2. Nada 3. Anytime 4. Iloveoov | ||
Ghin
United States2391 Posts
On November 28 2006 21:11 jkillashark wrote: I find it greatly annoying that more than half the comments I see in the Power Rankings are very shallow and of poor quality, and quantity for that matter. I see people say, no you're wrong... that's it. They give no reasoning behind it. DJEtter knows what he's talking about. He put a lot of reason and thinking into these selections. I would really like to see the Power Rankings spark intelligent debates whenever they come out. But right now I see some people putting intelligent input and the majority putting half assed one line disagreements. Show some respect to DJEtter and put some thought into your criticisms. i agree 100% except replace annoying with amusing so i agree 99.074% | ||
Orome
Switzerland11984 Posts
On December 03 2006 17:06 TehKris wrote: 1. Savior. 2. Nada 3. Anytime 4. Iloveoov Go away. | ||
-Carlodajin-
Peru235 Posts
2. JulyZerg 3. IlOveOOv 4. XellOs[yG] | ||
omgbnetsux
United States3749 Posts
On December 04 2006 06:09 -Carlodajin- wrote: 1. AnyTime[gm] 2. JulyZerg 3. IlOveOOv 4. XellOs[yG] Worst list evar. July, Xellos, and Oov with no IPX? OKAY. | ||
stickman
136 Posts
On November 28 2006 21:11 jkillashark wrote: I find it greatly annoying that more than half the comments I see in the Power Rankings are very shallow and of poor quality, and quantity for that matter...no reasoning behind it...the majority putting half assed one line disagreements... I think you can replace "the Power Rankings" with "teamliquid.net" and your comments are as accurate, if not more. There's no reason to pick a bone with this particular thread since a bulk of mindless discussion is common throughout the forums. Such content is expected and perhaps even desired by the moderators. Because if it wasn't, why aren't the authors of every shallow post punished? If you don't like such conduct in discussion, you could endeavor to change it, but since it has been a tradition of TL.net since its inception, you might find difficulty. | ||
Myxomatosis
United States2392 Posts
On December 04 2006 06:09 -Carlodajin- wrote: 1. AnyTime[gm] 2. JulyZerg 3. IlOveOOv 4. XellOs[yG] are you serious or joking? | ||
-Carlodajin-
Peru235 Posts
On December 04 2006 16:05 Myxomatosis wrote: Show nested quote + On December 04 2006 06:09 -Carlodajin- wrote: 1. AnyTime[gm] 2. JulyZerg 3. IlOveOOv 4. XellOs[yG] are you serious or joking? Serious... I may change the IlOveOOv place in the future...since it depends on the last WCG result...I really admire IlOveOOv for his accomplishment... And actually is like this if I include SlayerS_`BoxeR` on the list... 1. SlayerS_`BoxeR` 2. AnyTime[gm] 3. JulyZerg 4. IlOveOOv 5. XellOs[yG] | ||
omgbnetsux
United States3749 Posts
| ||
Myxomatosis
United States2392 Posts
On December 04 2006 16:50 -Carlodajin- wrote: Show nested quote + On December 04 2006 16:05 Myxomatosis wrote: On December 04 2006 06:09 -Carlodajin- wrote: 1. AnyTime[gm] 2. JulyZerg 3. IlOveOOv 4. XellOs[yG] are you serious or joking? Serious... I may change the IlOveOOv place in the future...since it depends on the last WCG result...I really admire IlOveOOv for his accomplishment... And actually is like this if I include SlayerS_`BoxeR` on the list... 1. SlayerS_`BoxeR` 2. AnyTime[gm] 3. JulyZerg 4. IlOveOOv 5. XellOs[yG] Wow, do you even realize that BOXER DOESN'T PLAY ANYMORE and couldn't even be REMOTELY CONSIDERED on a "hot list" at the moment? You neglect to put even sAvior[gm] who is CLEARLY the best player at the moment. I'm not going to even go into why your list is wrong because I have a feeling you are going to refute my argument by saying "No... iloveOOv win wcg... NaDa has never played wcg.. OOv #1 macro.. cheater terran" You either have very poor English and as a result, cannot understand that a power ranking is different than a list of one's 5 favorite players, or you are just a hopeless moronic retard. I'm hoping it's the first one. | ||
-Carlodajin-
Peru235 Posts
On December 04 2006 16:50 omgbnetsux wrote: Power rankings are based upon current trends.... You do realize this right? Yeah but my ranking its more like a...all time favorites list... | ||
mikeymoo
Canada7170 Posts
| ||
Orome
Switzerland11984 Posts
On December 04 2006 10:37 stickman wrote: Show nested quote + On November 28 2006 21:11 jkillashark wrote: I find it greatly annoying that more than half the comments I see in the Power Rankings are very shallow and of poor quality, and quantity for that matter...no reasoning behind it...the majority putting half assed one line disagreements... I think you can replace "the Power Rankings" with "teamliquid.net" and your comments are as accurate, if not more. There's no reason to pick a bone with this particular thread since a bulk of mindless discussion is common throughout the forums. Such content is expected and perhaps even desired by the moderators. Because if it wasn't, why aren't the authors of every shallow post punished? If you don't like such conduct in discussion, you could endeavor to change it, but since it has been a tradition of TL.net since its inception, you might find difficulty. TL has always had a strict line of moderating, and as a result, their forums have by far the best quality out of all non-korean SC sites (just look at gg.net's forums -_-). And also, how exactly would you punish shallow posts? Ban every poster, so that we're left with 50 people, and all the rest quit SC and progaming? | ||
stickman
136 Posts
On December 05 2006 02:09 Orome wrote: Show nested quote + On December 04 2006 10:37 stickman wrote: On November 28 2006 21:11 jkillashark wrote: I find it greatly annoying that more than half the comments I see in the Power Rankings are very shallow and of poor quality, and quantity for that matter...no reasoning behind it...the majority putting half assed one line disagreements... I think you can replace "the Power Rankings" with "teamliquid.net" and your comments are as accurate, if not more. There's no reason to pick a bone with this particular thread since a bulk of mindless discussion is common throughout the forums. Such content is expected and perhaps even desired by the moderators. Because if it wasn't, why aren't the authors of every shallow post punished? If you don't like such conduct in discussion, you could endeavor to change it, but since it has been a tradition of TL.net since its inception, you might find difficulty. TL has always had a strict line of moderating, and as a result, their forums have by far the best quality out of all non-korean SC sites (just look at gg.net's forums -_-). And also, how exactly would you punish shallow posts? Ban every poster, so that we're left with 50 people, and all the rest quit SC and progaming? Perhaps tl.net is the best quality of any non-Korean SC site, but the quality is much worse than other forums (not SC related). I don't know why you're asking me how I would punish shallow posters. Like I said, it's part of the forums that the administrators desire but don't encourage. There is a balance between popularity and quality and this forum has settled at a point and I'm not judging it at all. My point was just that it seemed a bit funny for jkillashark to bring that up in this thread when I think it's omnipresent and obvious. In my opinion, the English-speaking SC community can't support a lively forum that bans all shallow posters. The percentage of people in the SC community who would be good posters (ie have knowledge, time and willingness) is not high enough, considering how small the total population is, to support a lively forum. The number would dip too small to make good use of the forum medium. Maybe I'm wrong and there could be such a forum. However it'd be crazy for TL.net to risk the good thing they have going here just to find out. | ||
Hot_Bid
Braavos36362 Posts
On December 04 2006 19:20 -Carlodajin- wrote: Show nested quote + On December 04 2006 16:50 omgbnetsux wrote: Power rankings are based upon current trends.... You do realize this right? Yeah but my ranking its more like a...all time favorites list... well ive decided to make a list that ranks them alphabetically 1. [Red]Nada 2. Anytime[gm] 3. Bisu 4. Boxer 5. Savior | ||
jkillashark
United States5262 Posts
On December 05 2006 12:36 stickman wrote: Show nested quote + On December 05 2006 02:09 Orome wrote: On December 04 2006 10:37 stickman wrote: On November 28 2006 21:11 jkillashark wrote: I find it greatly annoying that more than half the comments I see in the Power Rankings are very shallow and of poor quality, and quantity for that matter...no reasoning behind it...the majority putting half assed one line disagreements... I think you can replace "the Power Rankings" with "teamliquid.net" and your comments are as accurate, if not more. There's no reason to pick a bone with this particular thread since a bulk of mindless discussion is common throughout the forums. Such content is expected and perhaps even desired by the moderators. Because if it wasn't, why aren't the authors of every shallow post punished? If you don't like such conduct in discussion, you could endeavor to change it, but since it has been a tradition of TL.net since its inception, you might find difficulty. TL has always had a strict line of moderating, and as a result, their forums have by far the best quality out of all non-korean SC sites (just look at gg.net's forums -_-). And also, how exactly would you punish shallow posts? Ban every poster, so that we're left with 50 people, and all the rest quit SC and progaming? Perhaps tl.net is the best quality of any non-Korean SC site, but the quality is much worse than other forums (not SC related). I don't know why you're asking me how I would punish shallow posters. Like I said, it's part of the forums that the administrators desire but don't encourage. There is a balance between popularity and quality and this forum has settled at a point and I'm not judging it at all. My point was just that it seemed a bit funny for jkillashark to bring that up in this thread when I think it's omnipresent and obvious. In my opinion, the English-speaking SC community can't support a lively forum that bans all shallow posters. The percentage of people in the SC community who would be good posters (ie have knowledge, time and willingness) is not high enough, considering how small the total population is, to support a lively forum. The number would dip too small to make good use of the forum medium. Maybe I'm wrong and there could be such a forum. However it'd be crazy for TL.net to risk the good thing they have going here just to find out. Way to go Sigmund and Freud on me. I only wrote that to encourage the so called "shallow posters" to think more about their posts in the future. I'm sorry if my comment hurt your feelings D=. I know it's rampant over teamliquid.net but why the hell would moderators desire such posts? | ||
| ||
Next event in 43m
[ Submit Event ] |
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 Counter-Strike Super Smash Bros Other Games Organizations Other Games StarCraft: Brood War StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War
StarCraft 2 • gosughost_ 28 StarCraft: Brood War• musti20045 26 • Kozan • Laughngamez YouTube • Poblha • aXEnki • intothetv • Gussbus • Migwel • IndyKCrew • LaughNgamez Trovo Dota 2 League of Legends |
Korean StarCraft League
Afreeca Starleague
hero vs Soulkey
AfreecaTV Pro Series
Reynor vs Cure
ESL Pro Tour
World Team League
ESL Pro Tour
BSL
Zhanhun vs DragOn
Dewalt vs Sziky
CSO Cup
Replay Cast
Sparkling Tuna Cup
[ Show More ] ESL Pro Tour
World Team League
ESL Pro Tour
BSL
Gypsy vs Bonyth
Mihu vs XiaoShuai
ESL Open Cup
ESL Open Cup
ESL Open Cup
ESL Pro Tour
ESL Pro Tour
ESL Pro Tour
ESL Pro Tour
|
|