|
United States12607 Posts
On August 04 2009 01:19 MuffinDude wrote: I'm pretty sure effort's game v great wasn't a nine pool speed but nine pool lair. hmmm...let me go back and check the VOD again...
Yes! You are right. Thank you for catching that, I'll fix it in the PR.
|
United States12607 Posts
On August 04 2009 01:19 MuffinDude wrote: Jangbi's playoff resume was more impressive than skyhigh's. When cj v khan game ended, Jangbi was at 4 - 1 and skyhigh was at 3 - 1. Skyhigh pulled ahead because he played two more games and I'm pretty sure jangbi could take on anyone on oz except for jaedong with relative ease. I think 2-0ing Leta was even huger than one super ace win.
|
jaedong Top Check
The view for bisu and fantasy is still the same
|
I like this , gj
first post in ages :s
|
On August 04 2009 01:28 JWD wrote:Show nested quote +On August 04 2009 01:19 MuffinDude wrote: Jangbi's playoff resume was more impressive than skyhigh's. When cj v khan game ended, Jangbi was at 4 - 1 and skyhigh was at 3 - 1. Skyhigh pulled ahead because he played two more games and I'm pretty sure jangbi could take on anyone on oz except for jaedong with relative ease. Exactly...Skyhigh did play more games. Though JB was held back by Stork's loss, his "hypothetical wins" just aren't as convincing as Skyhigh's actual ones. Not to mention that I think 2-0ing Leta was even huger than one super ace win.
Lol, leta was a fbh. 0 - 3 0 - 4? It was pretty bad.
And his game v snow was one of the most one sided game i've ever watched.
|
Calm in top 5? Excellent. The rest, I could care less about.
|
|
|
|
On August 04 2009 01:58 mel_ee wrote: sigh only one protoss.. its okay. it'll be fall soon
|
IMO, the SKT1 players' ranks are inflated. It is quite easy to look strong and win in a dominating fashion if you don't have to prepare for a large number of games. Also, it takes the stress off your PL practice if you know you have 3 other strong teammates.
On the other hand, I don't really see Calm or Effort being placed above Fantasy/Bisu either =(. However, I would have placed Iris above Canata. If you were allowed to leave places bank, though, I'd leave 2&3 blank, put Fantasy/Bisu at 4&5 and continue from there...
|
i kept reading, alt-tabbing, and then coming back to realize i had so much more to read. thank you for a nice and long PR agree with all your placements, although i think your proleague results > individual results tilt should have calm and effort switched
|
Philadelphia, PA10406 Posts
On August 04 2009 02:23 B1nary wrote: IMO, the SKT1 players' ranks are inflated. It is quite easy to look strong and win in a dominating fashion if you don't have to prepare for a large number of games. Also, it takes the stress off your PL practice if you know you have 3 other strong teammates.
On the other hand, I don't really see Calm or Effort being placed above Fantasy/Bisu either =(. However, I would have placed Iris above Canata. If you were allowed to leave places bank, though, I'd leave 2&3 blank, put Fantasy/Bisu at 4&5 and continue from there... Kinda defeats the point, doesn't it? The funny thing is that last month, it seemed like there was a shortage of good candidates for the PR, but this month there are too many good performers.
I mean, it's hard to dispute that Bisu and fantasy are in the top five players around right now. And they've really done nothing that would indicate that they'd slipped. Their silence is actually an indication of how well they've played, as SKT1 is already in the grand finals.
On August 04 2009 02:05 FragKrag wrote: Flash is off! YES!
Seconded. He's been sidelined by a severe case of the fingerbooms.
+ Show Spoiler +And I said this in the other thread, but PerfectMan for CNBC. Obviously.
|
On August 04 2009 02:46 tree.hugger wrote:And I said this in the other thread, but PerfectMan for CNBC. Obviously. Why Perfectman? He did not do anything extrodinary. He displayed pro-level reaver micro; but that was it. He had ample time to prepare and was obviously sent out to snipe Iris. There was no innovation in his play. All he did was execute a perfect snipe. If anyone should be on CNBC it should be Orion. His JD snipe was MUCH more impressive than Perfectman's.
|
Great Power Rank!
I would have liked it more though if you had FireBatHero in Not Close, But no Cigar. His playoff performance was atrocious.
|
Good PR.
Glad to see type-b make it.
|
United States12607 Posts
On August 04 2009 02:54 Athos wrote: I would have liked it more though if you had FireBatHero in Not Close, But no Cigar. His playoff performance was atrocious. No doubt FBH was awful in playoffs, but so far I have been trying to reserve NCANC for guys who were on the PR last month and have sucked since. There are too many bad players to include all of them in that section
|
I never EVER thought I'd see 5 zergs on the PR. Man times sure have changed.
|
I think you went a little too hard on Kal. He played good vs JangBi despite losing and crushed Yoon completely. Although his series vs JD was just awful (not only did JD play terrific but Kal just played very poorly), I don't think he did worse than expected compared to say Leta. I mean what Protoss DO you expect to beat JD in a Bo3? Bisu? Maybe.
|
Oh man, every time I look over and see the PR bar with Calm at #4 I'm going to get tingly all over.
Nice rank. My only real gripe is rating Effort above Iris.
|
|
|
|