|
Parting is not Top 15 GOAT, nor even Top 5 GOAT for Protoss (Zest, Classic, sOs, Rain, MC are all ahead of him).
Winning major trophies matter. And Parting hasn't done that. Those Top 5 Protoss have all won majors consistently more than Parting. He's good and plays entertainingly, but he's no winner material (at least, not yet).
Edit: herO is arguably in top 5 Protoss. But point here being that Parting clearly isn't, anyway.
|
1001 YEARS KESPAJAIL22271 Posts
Life isnt even anywhere close to 1.1 and 1.5 is even being generous
|
Do you think we should have the new list before 2020 ?
|
Nah.. In the year 2019, I couldn't take another list with MVP as no.1.
|
I think it's time for an LotV version at least. Definitely Stats would be at the top of it though but good argument could be made for Inno, Maru, Rogue, Serral and maybe Dark.
|
On March 03 2019 04:00 Anc13nt wrote: I think it's time for an LotV version at least. Definitely Stats would be at the top of it though but good argument could be made for Inno, Maru, Rogue, Serral and maybe Dark.
Dark actually needs to win something, Anything ))
|
LotV GOATs would be interesting at this point. Probably something like...
1) Stats 2) Dark 3) TY 4) Maru 5) Bogus 6) Serral 7) Solar 8) Rogue 9) Zest 10) soO
Choosing between TY, Maru and Bogus is tough. I think TY has the edge for greater consistency.
edit: ack, forgot about soO ><. ByuN out.
|
On March 03 2019 05:23 FrostedMiniWheats wrote:LotV GOATs would be interesting at this point. Probably something like... 1) Stats2) Dark3) TY4) Maru5) Bogus6) Serral 7) Rogue8) Solar9) Zest10) ByuNChoosing between TY, Maru and Bogus is tough. I think TY has the edge for greater consistency. Would probably put Zest above Solar, because his peak in early LotV was so high and the most consistent period of being at the top either of the two had across LotV. Very inconsistent both of these guys. But overall that list isn't too objectionable. Wondering if ByuN is too low though.
|
On March 03 2019 05:23 FrostedMiniWheats wrote:LotV GOATs would be interesting at this point. Probably something like... 1) Stats2) Dark3) TY4) Maru5) Bogus6) Serral 7) Solar8) Rogue9) Zest10) ByuNChoosing between TY, Maru and Bogus is tough. I think TY has the edge for greater consistency. I'd have Maru and Bogus over TY and Dark but I can see why you'd do it differently if you value consistency over trophies. Also I'd put Rogue over Serral and Solar is too high imo
|
On March 03 2019 05:31 Charoisaur wrote:I'd have Maru and Bogus over TY and Dark but I can see why you'd do it differently if you value consistency over trophies. Also I'd put Rogue over Serral and Solar is too high imo I 100% agree that Stats is number just through his sheer consistency, idk if I would have Dark #2 but there is at least an argument for it
|
On March 03 2019 05:36 starkiller123 wrote:Show nested quote +On March 03 2019 05:31 Charoisaur wrote:On March 03 2019 05:23 FrostedMiniWheats wrote:LotV GOATs would be interesting at this point. Probably something like... 1) Stats2) Dark3) TY4) Maru5) Bogus6) Serral 7) Solar8) Rogue9) Zest10) ByuNChoosing between TY, Maru and Bogus is tough. I think TY has the edge for greater consistency. I'd have Maru and Bogus over TY and Dark but I can see why you'd do it differently if you value consistency over trophies. Also I'd put Rogue over Serral and Solar is too high imo I 100% agree that Stats is number just through his sheer consistency, idk if I would have Dark #2 but there is at least an argument for it I mean really we can hardly even call Dark and Stats consistent anymore at this point. We basically take it for granted by now that they show up in the top 4 of big tournaments every few months. Stats even had a time where he was there every month.
|
What would this based on? Premier titles? Earnings? Stats has been the most consistent player in LoTV, he could very well be #1; both Maru, Rogue and guess-who should be way higher on this list.
|
On March 03 2019 07:05 Xain0n wrote: What would this based on? Premier titles? Earnings? Stats has been the most consistent player in LoTV, he could very well be #1; both Maru, Rogue and guess-who should be way higher on this list. INnoVation, glad we agree
|
On March 03 2019 07:10 starkiller123 wrote:Show nested quote +On March 03 2019 07:05 Xain0n wrote: What would this based on? Premier titles? Earnings? Stats has been the most consistent player in LoTV, he could very well be #1; both Maru, Rogue and guess-who should be way higher on this list. INnoVation, glad we agree
Not Inno of all people, no. We already had a list for HoTS.
|
Czech Republic12115 Posts
On March 03 2019 07:05 Xain0n wrote: What would this based on? Premier titles? Earnings? Stats has been the most consistent player in LoTV, he could very well be #1; both Maru, Rogue and guess-who should be way higher on this list. No? LotV is here 4 years now. Neither Maru, nor Rogue no guess-who shouldn't be higher. The list is quite spot on.
On March 03 2019 07:18 Xain0n wrote:Show nested quote +On March 03 2019 07:10 starkiller123 wrote:On March 03 2019 07:05 Xain0n wrote: What would this based on? Premier titles? Earnings? Stats has been the most consistent player in LoTV, he could very well be #1; both Maru, Rogue and guess-who should be way higher on this list. INnoVation, glad we agree Not Inno of all people, no. We already had a list for HoTS. Innovation was the best Terran of 2017... won GSL vs the World, GSL, SSL. While he had bad 2018(and part of the 2016), he was a beast.
|
Canada8759 Posts
On March 03 2019 07:10 starkiller123 wrote:Show nested quote +On March 03 2019 07:05 Xain0n wrote: What would this based on? Premier titles? Earnings? Stats has been the most consistent player in LoTV, he could very well be #1; both Maru, Rogue and guess-who should be way higher on this list. INnoVation, glad we agree INno has been pretty average in Lotv
|
On March 03 2019 07:36 deacon.frost wrote:Show nested quote +On March 03 2019 07:05 Xain0n wrote: What would this based on? Premier titles? Earnings? Stats has been the most consistent player in LoTV, he could very well be #1; both Maru, Rogue and guess-who should be way higher on this list. No? LotV is here 4 years now. Neither Maru, nor Rogue no guess-who shouldn't be higher. The list is quite spot on. Show nested quote +On March 03 2019 07:18 Xain0n wrote:On March 03 2019 07:10 starkiller123 wrote:On March 03 2019 07:05 Xain0n wrote: What would this based on? Premier titles? Earnings? Stats has been the most consistent player in LoTV, he could very well be #1; both Maru, Rogue and guess-who should be way higher on this list. INnoVation, glad we agree Not Inno of all people, no. We already had a list for HoTS. Innovation was the best Terran of 2017... won GSL vs the World, GSL, SSL. While he had bad 2018(and part of the 2016), he was a beast.
It hasn't been four years yet, you know. I just said Inno should not be higher, not that he should be lower.
|
On March 03 2019 07:39 Nakajin wrote:Show nested quote +On March 03 2019 07:10 starkiller123 wrote:On March 03 2019 07:05 Xain0n wrote: What would this based on? Premier titles? Earnings? Stats has been the most consistent player in LoTV, he could very well be #1; both Maru, Rogue and guess-who should be way higher on this list. INnoVation, glad we agree INno has been pretty average in Lotv 2017 was for the most part INno's year with 4 premier titles two of them star leagues, but sure average
|
On March 03 2019 07:56 starkiller123 wrote:Show nested quote +On March 03 2019 07:39 Nakajin wrote:On March 03 2019 07:10 starkiller123 wrote:On March 03 2019 07:05 Xain0n wrote: What would this based on? Premier titles? Earnings? Stats has been the most consistent player in LoTV, he could very well be #1; both Maru, Rogue and guess-who should be way higher on this list. INnoVation, glad we agree INno has been pretty average in Lotv 2017 was for the most part INno's year with 4 premier titles two of them star leagues, but sure average
true
|
Old thread, but my personal list as of today:
Ranking by Achievements + Performance (> means higher, >= means higher but I think there are arguments the right player could be slightly higher than the left, = means very equal but I would slightly favor the player on the left)
Maru > Innovation >= (Life >= MVP = Rogue) = Taeja >= (sOs = Dark = Serral) >= (Stats = Classic = MC = Polt) >= (MMA = Zest) >= Nestea >= (soO = Rain) > (Parting = herO)
S: Maru, Innovation A+: Life, MVP, Rogue A: Taeja A-: sOs, Dark, Serral B+: Stats, Classic, MC, Polt B: MMA, Zest, Nestea B-: soO, Rain C: Parting, herO
|
|
|
|