TL Mafia XXXV
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
| ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
| ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
also, TheMango is definitely red. Look at his name ^^; | ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
| ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
On January 01 2011 13:04 orgolove wrote: Wow. Opening an IRC channel in the main thread free for all the reds to view - really a great idea lol... ? You serious? It's exactly the same as the main thread, except the "posts" will be shorter, and more frequent. Why are you against discussion? | ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
Wouldn't be surprised if Opz hit Node and mafia stacked RoL. | ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
| ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
On January 04 2011 03:39 Barundar wrote: Believe me, I don't want to. Didn't you afk your way to get mislynched by DrH in Salem? Don't make it so hard on towns that wants to win please Nah DrH was just taking revenge that game cuz I was like "you bad" and then he was like "why me bad" and I was like "you bad" and he was like "Darth #1 Scum lynch plz" And orly. Why would I believe you ^^. | ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
| ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
On January 04 2011 17:26 orgolove wrote: Oh, I ask for two things: 1. ~OpZ~, did you explain your vig hit? What happened and why did a vet die? Did you hit RoL as well or what? 2. Meapak - if you continue to claim green, can you explain why you changed your vote from annul when his vote got close with my total during day 2? And according to a bird, you had gone to IRC and scolded people for voting on annul. What's with that? Learn to spell my name bro. And you haven't found much on me because I replaced partway into day 2, and haven't posted much because I can only react to things posted recently. But anyway, Opz admitted to hitting RoL, so that means mafia targeted RoL/Node last night. Assuming you're not mafia, if Mr. Zergling took that initiative to PM you outside of thread, I'd buy it. I'll be around for the next few hours and watch the votes to see I need to send my vote anywhere else, just looking to save myself atm. | ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
Thoughts: I didn't think Meapak was mafia (didn't know/care about GC), but I thought it'd be worse to have 10 townies suddenly change their votes, and then we lose a day's worth of information. | ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
opz, zergling, orgolove, lunardestiny, wiggles, barundar, GGQ possible mafia: seraph, insanious, pandain, d3, tree, shockeyy, jackal58 Since I was asked to look at GGQ specifically, here's some analysis: He hasn't posted too much, but he hasn't done anything scummy either, either than lack of posting I guess. Could be worse. Most of what he said day 1 is pretty logical and generic stuff, not a tell for either side. On December 28 2010 13:24 GGQ wrote: Yeah my bad. I was bus driver and redirected a mafia kill to you. You died to save a detective, though! LSB's advice in this game has been very similar to his posts in the pokemafia game where he was town, but he's gotten into an argument here which he carefully avoided in that game. I know he gave a reason for that already, but I think that it's not a good enough reason for this whole drawn-out argument. I'm not ready to vote for him, but it's worth noting. I don't know why annul is so focused on him. It was good to bring his spamminess to everyone's attention so he would be under the town's focus and forced to post more constructively, but it's not good to be tunnel-visioning him already. If this argument gets too much focus then everyone else will fly under the radar. This post, he's defending LSB and accusing annul subtly. Well, accusing is a strong word for it, but he's calling annul out for sure, while offering LSB some defense. On December 29 2010 03:23 GGQ wrote: But you were, in fact, a guerilla? How is that helping your argument here? Here he calls out annul for bad posting. On December 29 2010 04:48 GGQ wrote: I'm unsatisfied with this answer. No, if you did an analysis of me and FOSed me as mafia when I'm not, that in and of itself would not make me any more suspicious of you. In fact, active scumhunting would make you more likely to be town. As for his analysis being 'all lies', I don't see any lies in his analysis post. You may disagree with his opinions, or think his logic is weak, but that doesn't make him mafia. If you are town, you're the only one who knows that so it doesn't make sense to vote for someone just because they voted for you. What really worries me about this lynch is that besides deconduo there hasn't really been anyone trying to divert the lynch, so either LSB is town or his buddies are abandoning him. Brings up several good points about posting styles. Be wary of people that post like town, but don't do any scumhunting. Unforunately, LSB ended up beign town anyway, but these are all valid points. On December 29 2010 13:07 GGQ wrote: I don't particularly FOS you, but it should be pointed out that this doesn't clear you by a long shot. Mafia knows better than anyone who is clear, and it's very easy for them to buddy a townie to appear clean when he flips. As for annul and pandain, we shouldn't lynch them just because they are wrong. But we also shouldn't let them get away too easily. Some people have suggested that they wouldn't be so bold if they were mafia. But with the godfather and the framer(s) to mess with the DTs, mafia can afford to be pretty bold this game. Pointing out the possibility of annul being godfather... big no no if he was mafia. On December 31 2010 04:20 GGQ wrote: I feel that I should reveal this information since mafia already knows it; I was roleblocked last night. I just read through the entire thread again and here are my thoughts: -Pandain doesn't seem like scum to me, just a flip-flopping townie. -Brockett narrowly avoided a lynch and still hasn't contributed anything. Much fewer posts and different posting style than his townie play in Pokemafia -I'm still suspicious of TheMango but don't have solid reasoning for it -I am pretty confident that ROL is town, but I dont necessarily agree with all his picks for mafia -Insanious doesn't seem scummy to me. People keep saying that he was 'so sure' LSB was blue, but if you actually read his posts, that's not what he was saying -I'm on the fence about annul. I always thought his tunneling on LSB was stupid, but that doesn't make him mafia. He certainly could be, though -I'm most suspicious atm of Seraph (as ROL pointed out) and Mr Wiggles. While reading, I noticed that all of Mr Wiggles posts are riddled with uncertainty, fear, and unwillingness to commit. He may be a newer player, but it still makes me very susicious of him. My vote goes on him for now He got roleblocked. No one counterclaimed, right? And while it's possible that mafia dodged their first roleblock to make GGQ seem more legitimate, combine this with his other posts, and it's very very very likely that GGQ is town. On January 03 2011 03:43 GGQ wrote: How does someone going for you make them mafia? Barundar just added me to his suspects list, but I don't think he's mafia one little bit. Gotta love logic. Anyway, conclusion: GGQ is 90% town to me. | ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
I forgot to state explicity the general theme of my analysis: GGQ called annul out/brought attention to annul WAY too much to be mafia. At least in my opinion, as a mafia, you don't call out your teammates, except maybe once or twice for the whole game (unless they're already a lost cause/getting bused). And the likelihood of annul getting bused this game is pretty low, because he was their godfather pick. It's a little extreme to throw that advantage away this early. So, the fact that GGQ was on annul's case early makes me think that he's town. | ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
For those PMs, keep in mind that the last day's wagon was essentially between 3 townies (from my perspective). So there was no reason for the mafia to do anything too crazy because they didn't need to protect anyone really. | ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
| ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
On January 09 2011 08:00 Mr. Wiggles wrote: I'm just wondering what the reasoning or logic is behind it. What is the proof that he fake-claimed it? Without giving any specifics, do you have a solid reason for believing he lied, as in actual evidence, not just a hunch? My guess is that he said so himself. lol. 3 veterans is pretty crazy. Really reduces the expected number of medics that we have. esp with a framer, a godfather, and an alleged roleblocker, we should still have some blues though. KP tells us that there are 3 mafia left 99% sure. Do we have any vigilantes? I wouldn't mind seeing any of Shockeyy/Pandain/orgolove hit tonight to clear things up. Esp. Shockeyy since the others are iffy. If we have a DT, he better be in contact with Opz, so that we can get some information out. With... 3? 4? checks down, we'll have this game in the bag I think. | ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
6. TheMango 7. Mr.Zergling 8. why 9. Jackal58 11. Barundar 15. ShoCkeyy 17. ilovejonn 19. Orgolove 20. Pandain 24. d3_crescentia 27. Soulfire 29. DarthThienAn 30. ~OpZ~ 13 total, so 10 vs 3 imo - Considering that no blues are dead still, I'd say Opz is pretty confirmed. My mafia list from before still stands (minus dead): pandain, d3, shockeyy, jackal58 havent heard from TheMango in awhile o.o is he still in the game? | ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
What will his death tell us when he flips town? That... he had such and such an opinion. okay. Why aren't we lynching ShoCkeyy or Pandain? | ||
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
On January 11 2011 07:23 ~OpZ~ wrote: Cuz roleblocker's existence was confirmed by GGQ. Either mafia are insane, and had framer and thought no DT was in the game (doesn't make sense), and wasted several days of Roleblocking by blocking only Pandain, OR NOT BLOCKING AT ALL <---- Does not make sense. So....With that said...Either Pandain is an evil genius and called NO DT in game, or he is town. I'd lynch barundar. I'm fine lynching you. You posted an analysis of GGQ....then he died, what, a few hours later? Yea. Where has your analysis like that been? Not in this game. You need to go. Even if your town, you haven't been useful at all. Opz #1 scumhunter. Making great use of your status as a confirmed role. And what happens when you mislynch, putting town at 7v3 after night? Eh, whatever. Have fun. | ||
| ||