Website Feedback
Closed Threads
IRC Chat
irc.quakenet.org #teamliquid
IRC Web ClientTeamSpeak 3 (84 users) | |
|
| Gnosis Canada. September 30 2011 23:05. Posts 827 | Profile # |
On September 30 2011 22:45 dangots0ul wrote:
Show nested quote +On September 30 2011 20:26 Tschis wrote:+ Show Spoiler +
I loved the episode, and I was dying for a new episode, really. But two things hit me hard in this first one, I thought it was complete bullshit lol
First, it was the "1 million? No problem. <looks around, there's a table with a $100.000 buyin where nobody cheats> easy! 30 seconds of episode and he got $1,000,000
I facepalmed at this moment >.<
The second part I really didn't like was how he was completely free of all charges, after commiting murder. I mean, seriously? Does the law in US works like this? I've never seen this on the News, on TV Shows or movies. Guy goes completely free just because the guy he killed was a serial killer? It's still murder...
jury nullification man. Its technically possible, though unrealistic. But all of these law and order spin offs (and most TV for that matter) are absurd and unrealistic if you think about it.
I'm alright with suspending disbelief, but the season premier required too much. Very disappointed.
Last edit: 2011-09-30 23:15:36 |
| | "Reason is flawless, de jure, but reasoners are not, de facto." – Peter Kreeft |
|
|
| Slusher United States. October 03 2011 14:21. Posts 2440 | Profile Blog # |
On September 30 2011 23:05 Gnosis wrote:
Show nested quote +On September 30 2011 22:45 dangots0ul wrote:
On September 30 2011 20:26 Tschis wrote:+ Show Spoiler +
I loved the episode, and I was dying for a new episode, really. But two things hit me hard in this first one, I thought it was complete bullshit lol
First, it was the "1 million? No problem. <looks around, there's a table with a $100.000 buyin where nobody cheats> easy! 30 seconds of episode and he got $1,000,000
I facepalmed at this moment >.<
The second part I really didn't like was how he was completely free of all charges, after commiting murder. I mean, seriously? Does the law in US works like this? I've never seen this on the News, on TV Shows or movies. Guy goes completely free just because the guy he killed was a serial killer? It's still murder...
jury nullification man. Its technically possible, though unrealistic. But all of these law and order spin offs (and most TV for that matter) are absurd and unrealistic if you think about it.
I'm alright with suspending disbelief, but the season premier required too much. Very disappointed.
What I love about this show is how cheesy it is, every episode is this ridiculous and that is exactly why I watch it. I mean do you really want to take issue with this episode after The Biker gang episode, the episode where Jane solves a crime from jail?? just to name a few.Last edit: 2011-10-03 14:22:26 |
|
|
| Tschis Brazil. October 03 2011 21:27. Posts 1466 | Profile # |
On October 03 2011 14:21 Slusher wrote:
Show nested quote +On September 30 2011 23:05 Gnosis wrote:
On September 30 2011 22:45 dangots0ul wrote:
On September 30 2011 20:26 Tschis wrote:+ Show Spoiler +
I loved the episode, and I was dying for a new episode, really. But two things hit me hard in this first one, I thought it was complete bullshit lol
First, it was the "1 million? No problem. <looks around, there's a table with a $100.000 buyin where nobody cheats> easy! 30 seconds of episode and he got $1,000,000
I facepalmed at this moment >.<
The second part I really didn't like was how he was completely free of all charges, after commiting murder. I mean, seriously? Does the law in US works like this? I've never seen this on the News, on TV Shows or movies. Guy goes completely free just because the guy he killed was a serial killer? It's still murder...
jury nullification man. Its technically possible, though unrealistic. But all of these law and order spin offs (and most TV for that matter) are absurd and unrealistic if you think about it.
I'm alright with suspending disbelief, but the season premier required too much. Very disappointed.
What I love about this show is how cheesy it is, every episode is this ridiculous and that is exactly why I watch it. I mean do you really want to take issue with this episode after The Biker gang episode, the episode where Jane solves a crime from jail?? just to name a few.
I like to take into consideration the "universe" in which the series is held on. In The Mentalist's universe, Jane is smart enough to solve that crime from jail, that's why I don't have a problem with it.
For example, in Smallville, Clark has superpowers, it's normal for that universe, that's why I don't have any problem with other people showing up with other kind of super powers. But I can't stand when some stuff happen and they're weird even for that universe, like when a guy, whose super power is super-speed, uses a wooden baseball bat to hit Clark, and Clark is throw a bunch of meters into the air... how's that possible, even within that universe, that wooden bat doesn't breakm, and instead it hurts Clark? It makes no sense even for that universe.
In a non-related question, what do you guys think will happen if Red John murder another girl? This will show that RJ is not dead and then Jane will have to be in trial again? |
| | "A coward is not someone that runs from a battle knowing he will lose. A coward is someone who challenges a weak knowing he will win." |
|
|
| Adila United States. October 03 2011 21:37. Posts 750 | Profile # |
On October 03 2011 21:27 Tschis wrote:
Show nested quote +On October 03 2011 14:21 Slusher wrote:
On September 30 2011 23:05 Gnosis wrote:
On September 30 2011 22:45 dangots0ul wrote:
On September 30 2011 20:26 Tschis wrote:+ Show Spoiler +
I loved the episode, and I was dying for a new episode, really. But two things hit me hard in this first one, I thought it was complete bullshit lol
First, it was the "1 million? No problem. <looks around, there's a table with a $100.000 buyin where nobody cheats> easy! 30 seconds of episode and he got $1,000,000
I facepalmed at this moment >.<
The second part I really didn't like was how he was completely free of all charges, after commiting murder. I mean, seriously? Does the law in US works like this? I've never seen this on the News, on TV Shows or movies. Guy goes completely free just because the guy he killed was a serial killer? It's still murder...
jury nullification man. Its technically possible, though unrealistic. But all of these law and order spin offs (and most TV for that matter) are absurd and unrealistic if you think about it.
I'm alright with suspending disbelief, but the season premier required too much. Very disappointed.
What I love about this show is how cheesy it is, every episode is this ridiculous and that is exactly why I watch it. I mean do you really want to take issue with this episode after The Biker gang episode, the episode where Jane solves a crime from jail?? just to name a few.
I like to take into consideration the "universe" in which the series is held on. In The Mentalist's universe, Jane is smart enough to solve that crime from jail, that's why I don't have a problem with it. For example, in Smallville, Clark has superpowers, it's normal for that universe, that's why I don't have any problem with other people showing up with other kind of super powers. But I can't stand when some stuff happen and they're weird even for that universe, like when a guy, whose super power is super-speed, uses a wooden baseball bat to hit Clark, and Clark is throw a bunch of meters into the air... how's that possible, even within that universe, that wooden bat doesn't breakm, and instead it hurts Clark? It makes no sense even for that universe. In a non-related question, what do you guys think will happen if Red John murder another girl? This will show that RJ is not dead and then Jane will have to be in trial again?
I think double jeopardy applies. Jane cannot be re-tried for the same crime unless there's a whole bunch of legal wrangling going on in the background we don't know about. |
|
|
| Arthemesia United States. October 03 2011 23:03. Posts 257 | Profile # |
| ^ In theory he could be tried again if he was tried for the murder of a specific person and not Red John. The only thing that bothers me with this show is that because Red John is so elusive and covers so many people will the ending really do it justice and they'll have a lot of ground to cover to make sure it comes together well. |
|
|
| Tschis Brazil. October 04 2011 00:48. Posts 1466 | Profile # |
On October 03 2011 23:03 Arthemesia wrote:
^ In theory he could be tried again if he was tried for the murder of a specific person and not Red John. The only thing that bothers me with this show is that because Red John is so elusive and covers so many people will the ending really do it justice and they'll have a lot of ground to cover to make sure it comes together well.
Well, I think they set for 5 seasons, isn't that right? So that would be 40~ episodes to cover everything up. Should be enough.
|
| | "A coward is not someone that runs from a battle knowing he will lose. A coward is someone who challenges a weak knowing he will win." |
|
|
| Tschis Brazil. October 26 2011 20:18. Posts 1466 | Profile # |
Can anyone tell me what happened with Bertram? I don't recall anything happening to him for them to get a new boss. What's up with that?
ps.: Is anyone else bothered they didn't show what was in the box of LaRoche? |
| | "A coward is not someone that runs from a battle knowing he will lose. A coward is someone who challenges a weak knowing he will win." |
|
|
 Velocee October 26 2011 20:42. Posts 33 | Profile Blog # |
I was actually really really disappointed with the first episode this season. It seemed so rushed, they crammed an entire trial into one episode and he got off scot-free, despite murdering someone. But he has such charm. And such a mischievous smile! Anyways, the most recent one, on the island, is a pretty random episode. I quite enjoyed it though.
Also yes, Tschis, I am bothered that I don't know what is in LaRoches little box. |
|
|
| era United States. November 04 2011 14:20. Posts 199 | Profile # |
| Such a good episode tonight, the ending was great/ |
|
|
| Enervate United States. November 04 2011 14:33. Posts 1766 | Profile # |
| Yea I agree about the ending. At first, I thought the episode was kinda boring, predictable and cliche. But then when Jane's plan fails and things don't end happily ever after, I found it a lot more interesting. As soon as Jane got him talking about Red John, I was like GG. |
|
|
| DoX.) Singapore. November 04 2011 14:36. Posts 6155 | Profile # |
| oh my god i just god done watching the first three seasons like 2 days ago. Fuck this is intense. The cast really knows how to pull off emotional scenes i'll give'em that. The final minutes of 3x18 with Jane and Dr Steiner and 3x19 with Jane talking about his wife was d'awww ;( |
|
|
| mcmartini Australia. November 04 2011 17:28. Posts 1795 | Profile Blog # |
| Tonight episode was so good as soon as I saw them on TV and the blinking red light I knew what was going to happen :D So excited for the rest of this season :D |
| | I just want to say I have 370 APM - Liquid'Tyler SotG 14-12-2011 "I mean it's too bad you can't be paid to be, you know, a chicken shit fucking whiny bitch on the internet or we would have lots of rich community members" Nick "Tasteless" Plott |
|
|
| darksub Argentina. November 04 2011 18:16. Posts 296 | Profile # |
On November 04 2011 17:28 mcmartini wrote:
Tonight episode was so good as soon as I saw them on TV and the blinking red light I knew what was going to happen :D So excited for the rest of this season :D
same feeling |
| |
|
| Clearout Norway. November 04 2011 18:53. Posts 1010 | Profile # |
| Goddamn that was one epic ending. I kept thinking OH DAMN YOU DID IT NOW when he got him talking about Red John. Haven't been that excited from an episode since the series started. |
| |
|
| Railxp Hong Kong. November 04 2011 19:06. Posts 1308 | Profile Blog # |
love this show the same reason why i love watching House  |
| | ~\(｡◕‿‿◕｡)/~,,,,,,,,> - rawr hydraa <gwongthoughts.blogspot> |
|
|
| Grettin November 05 2011 07:45. Posts 20510 | Profile # |
Amazing episode this week and what a ending.  |
| | "If I had force-fields in Brood War, I'd never lose." -Bisu |
|
|
| BradPitlord Croatia. November 05 2011 23:02. Posts 30 | Profile # |
God damn! I really really hope that they will finally focus more on red john this season : D
|
| | "Not so long ago I said to a friend of mine: 'If I saw a kitten and a little human baby sitting on the curb starving, I would feed the kitten first if nobody was looking.' My friend said: 'I would feed the kitten first if somebody was looking'." |
|
|
| Phayze Canada. November 07 2011 04:04. Posts 2017 | Profile Blog # |
| So episode 5 of this season, Sarah Herrigan? I couldnt help but laugh my ass off it felt like such a Starcraft reference. She was an lawyer in a previous episode I guess, and she showed up from the public defenders office. Anyways, I lol'd. Anyone else notice? |
| | Proud member of the LGA-1366 Core-i7 4Ghz Club |
|
|
| Arthemesia United States. November 11 2011 12:05. Posts 257 | Profile # |
| Are they going to ignore what happened last episode? Man that really disappoints me. |
|
|
| TKHawkins United States. November 11 2011 12:22. Posts 102 | Profile # |
On November 11 2011 12:05 Arthemesia wrote:
Are they going to ignore what happened last episode? Man that really disappoints me.
They aren't.
Tonight is a re-run. |
|
|
| Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Next All | |
|
|
|
| |
|
Sidebar Settings...
|
Store
