TL Mafia XXXIX
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
| ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
| ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
On May 04 2011 18:33 chaoser wrote: There's no real such thing as a scum-tell per say. TL doesn't really do the MS "You said good job to medic when he saved someone, you're scum!" kind of deal but there are limitations to what mafia can and can't do. Or at least feel comfortable with doing. If you look at XXXVII, you'll see that mafia found it very hard to make cases against each other and that ended up catching a lot of them. If you look at XXXXVIII, you can see that mafia were decently wishy-washy. By wishy-washy I don't mean they changed their opinions on things, but that they changed them based upon nothing, merely to please the rest of town. In Simple Mafia, Town because Mafia were inactive and allowed town to dominate the discussion. Even so, you'll notice that most of the time it was town arguing against town, using weak arguments and trying to figure out alliances before anyone even flipped. That's bad play since you don't know how mafia will act towards each other. They could bus each other a bit, they could act friendly, or they might not interact at all. The point is that you should focus on a few people and then make judgements about connections AFTER the flip. On day one, conversation generation is the most important thing, even if it IS the 30th game we're discussing about lynching inactives or not. Pressure is also a good conversation generator and I know for a fact that GM's question asking helps too. Mafia wants town to have no direction and I'm sure in this game, where it's filled with mostly newbies, the mafia aren't going to go out of their way to help newbie townies. As such, redtooth get's +townie points in my book. Townies should be sure to ask coaches for help and read over guides conveniently localed here: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=215574 That's all fine and all but the thing I find extremelly suspicious about this post is this: Chaoser points out how redtooth post is pro-town and then he proceeds to do exactly what redtooth did. Why are making such a huge effort to appear pro-town chaoser? This post would have exactly the same content without the bolded part. The only thing this part adds is making YOU look more town. | ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
If your intention was really just helping out newbies you had no reason to say: "Look, helping out newbies is pro town okay?" What you did was copying someone's behaviour which you felt was pro-town and then made sure point it out. | ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
| ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
On May 04 2011 23:29 Rising_Phoenix wrote: Sorry I can't post while I'm asleep >.< Hi buddy! Also what's with all these vets posting huge guides of how to play the game? It's not like we can't read the guides already on this and other sites with useful information. We do need a leader to help lead conversation and we need to be certain that the person isn't mafia. I'm against a "day 1 inactive lynch" Unless we REALLY need to do it. Usually inactives are just disinterested townies, and if we go around lynching random people chances are we'll just hit a townie (simple math says 20% chance of mafia) I also don't see a point in talking about our previous games experience. Really it seems like an easy way to clutter a thread. If you want to see their previous games, go into their post history unless they have a smurf. It seems like we know the people with smurfs so does it really matter? And also isn't it illegal to have two accounts on the site? I feel huge day1 "newbies guides" are kinda useless and suspicious. While we definitely need direction, guides IN THREAD about how to play the game ore mostly filler. Most of what people said have been said are in guides both on this and other sites. I'm not saying it's suspicious but I am saying it's unnecessary and in general a pretty useless post. This post is the scummiest I've seen so far. He shuts down all ideas as useless, states the obvious multiple times and he even feels the need of repeating himself to make his post larger. He closes it in a beautiful whishy-washy fashion. | ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
| ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
| ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
| ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
Are you claiming you are doing it on purpose? | ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
| ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
| ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
| ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
Kurumi So, from what I can gather his plan was to behave like scum, add a lot of cconfusion, spam the thread like a mad man, just to see who would acuse him of being scum. Because, I mean, if you think someone who's being extremtly scummy is scum, then YOU must be scum, right? RIGHT? No. Irish_Punk Jumped in to kurumi's defense claiming he's made great posts, but nobody seems to be able to find them. Guess what, they do not exist. He either knows kurumi is town or he knows kurumi is scum. Either way he is scum. Killer_SOS Agrees with Irish_Punk for no reason. Then chainsaw's against chaos13. Has many fillers and one liners with no content. I feel this guy is scum, but he's not a good day1 lynch for obvious reasons. Rising_Phoenix I would like you to look at this post (which I already stated why I find it very scummy): On May 04 2011 23:29 Rising_Phoenix wrote: Sorry I can't post while I'm asleep >.< Hi buddy! Also what's with all these vets posting huge guides of how to play the game? It's not like we can't read the guides already on this and other sites with useful information. We do need a leader to help lead conversation and we need to be certain that the person isn't mafia. I'm against a "day 1 inactive lynch" Unless we REALLY need to do it. Usually inactives are just disinterested townies, and if we go around lynching random people chances are we'll just hit a townie (simple math says 20% chance of mafia) I also don't see a point in talking about our previous games experience. Really it seems like an easy way to clutter a thread. If you want to see their previous games, go into their post history unless they have a smurf. It seems like we know the people with smurfs so does it really matter? And also isn't it illegal to have two accounts on the site? I feel huge day1 "newbies guides" are kinda useless and suspicious. While we definitely need direction, guides IN THREAD about how to play the game ore mostly filler. Most of what people said have been said are in guides both on this and other sites. I'm not saying it's suspicious but I am saying it's unnecessary and in general a pretty useless post. And then compare it to this post: On April 24 2011 04:50 Rising_Phoenix wrote: ##Unvote Sorry I was at a horn concert and doing some other stuff as well. First, looking at this mathematically there are 11 players, 3 of which are mafia. If you randomly choose a person there is a approx. 27% chance of getting it right. However, choosing randomly is a bad idea since you never know if you're lynching an important member (cop or medic). The cop should look up a random member that isn't himself(obviously). That means there is a 3 in 10 chance of him being right (30%). If he is right, he should be able to hint to everyone else who is mafia. That leaves everyone else voting on another person. If you know who the cop/detective is, that leaves a 3 in 9 chance (33%) of being right. That's from 1/5 to 1/3 probability of being right. I don't know how well this works for day one but numbers are fun =]. ----- Break for other half--- Leadership for townies is essential, and right now it looks like Conversion and Freestalker are the two most active in leading conversation and topics. Unless one of them slips up, I'd refrain from killing either of them for now. Silent members have three possibilities: 1)They're trying to hide 2)They're lazy or disinterested in the game 3)It's a holiday and they're traveling Going through we have these people being pretty inactive: -jaminz: a few filler posts, nothing as contribution to the thread, pointing fingers -aScle: one post? -Enervate: very little posting as well These players have said very little or immediately start pointing fingers (Enervate) when they start pointing. However, it doesn't make sense to choose him because he hasn't bothered defending any accusations or contributing anything to support his claim. aScle and Jaminz have had very little to contribute. Their posts have little to no content and have not been active in general. Also, Jaminz has been very ready to point fingers but has little supporting evidence. I'll vote for him since he's just detracting from town synergy. So, unless he can defend himself: ##vote Jaminz This post is from newbie mini mafia I, in which he was scum and won a flawless victory. Note the similarities. Redtooth Holy shit, my whole team is exposing themselves like crazy. Time to chainsaw and discredit chaoser! I fail to see how this players you are calling obvtown are obvtown. Your logic is pretty fail: kurumi and irish_punk are so blatantly scum that they MUST NOT be scum so they MUST be town. If you keep following this logic doesn't this make them obvscum all over again? Then he picks Killer_SOS to focus on for day1 lynch. That's pretty dumb if you are town. That's all I have to say for now. | ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
@kurumi: No. If you read the first line it says FOS list. For example if Redtooth is red, than most likely KillerSOS is not and so on. | ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
| ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
| ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
| ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
| ||
sandroba
Canada4932 Posts
| ||
| ||