| Maverick32x United States. March 01 2012 12:30. Posts 282 | Profile # |
I agree- We should get a first day lynch if possible. I see your point OtoshimonU about being at a disadvantage- but I think we won't be gathering any information if we DON'T lynch.... plus it gives mafia a free kill on the first night. I hope everyone stays active since that is pretty much the only way we will be able win.
One question to you Trackdoor, you say "Don't be afraid to accuse anyone", but we really don't know ANYTHING right now. I'd like to try to stick to the facts/logic that are presented. Your post sounds really bold for being a first post. I'm not saying there is anything particularly scummy about that.. just something I noticed! |
|
|
| OtoshimonoU United States. March 01 2012 12:34. Posts 470 | Profile # |
On March 01 2012 12:30 Maverick32x wrote:
I agree- We should get a first day lynch if possible. I see your point OtoshimonU about being at a disadvantage- but I think we won't be gathering any information if we DON'T lynch.... plus it gives mafia a free kill on the first night. I hope everyone stays active since that is pretty much the only way we will be able win.
One question to you Trackdoor, you say "Don't be afraid to accuse anyone", but we really don't know ANYTHING right now. I'd like to try to stick to the facts/logic that are presented. Your post sounds really bold for being a first post. I'm not saying there is anything particularly scummy about that.. just something I noticed!
I do believe that he got that quote from a Mafia Guide here on TL, and also it's his second time playing so he might have more experience that any of first timers. |
| |
|
| OtoshimonoU United States. March 01 2012 12:37. Posts 470 | Profile # |
On March 01 2012 12:34 OtoshimonoU wrote:
Show nested quote +On March 01 2012 12:30 Maverick32x wrote:
I agree- We should get a first day lynch if possible. I see your point OtoshimonU about being at a disadvantage- but I think we won't be gathering any information if we DON'T lynch.... plus it gives mafia a free kill on the first night. I hope everyone stays active since that is pretty much the only way we will be able win.
One question to you Trackdoor, you say "Don't be afraid to accuse anyone", but we really don't know ANYTHING right now. I'd like to try to stick to the facts/logic that are presented. Your post sounds really bold for being a first post. I'm not saying there is anything particularly scummy about that.. just something I noticed!
I do believe that he got that quote from a Mafia Guide here on TL, and also it's his second time playing so he might have more experience that any of first timers.
Or maybe I confused his words with the mafia guide... Anyway, if everyone is willing to random lynch I will too, |
| |
|
| gunman103 United States. March 01 2012 12:38. Posts 84 | Profile # |
On March 01 2012 12:14 DimmuKlok wrote:
I too feel that we should push for a lynch on day one. Mafia has nothing to lose with with a no lynch on day one, where the town loses the potential for more information with a lynch. That's why it's crucial that everyone posts their opinions on topics and stays active so we can get reads on everyone.
I agree. However, we will lose our number advantage more rapidly if we do lynch someone just for the sake of lynching. If there's no potential for information to be gained by lynching him, then we should not do so. |
|
|
| trackd00r Chile. March 01 2012 12:41. Posts 283 | Profile Blog # |
Yeah, that phrase was regarding any moment of the game. In my last game, I actually nailed some scum reads on day 3, but as I didn't take an active role in the thread and many already drew suspicion upon me it was practically impossible to push them in that moment. That's why I make that clear.
By the way, that's the kind of observation we need Maverick. I appreciate that.
I just hope we won't have many inactive players the following hours. |
| | ''They put signs, but I can't read'' |
|
|
| OtoshimonoU United States. March 01 2012 12:46. Posts 470 | Profile # |
| Sorry fellas, I have to go too sleep. I will check as frequent as possible. The day lasts a long time so I hope to see more things before my vote. |
| |
|
| Sufficiency Canada. March 01 2012 12:57. Posts 7290 | Profile Blog # |
| NVM. 9 townies 3 mafia. We got at least 2 free lynch. Last edit: 2012-03-01 13:01:05 |
| |
|
| Sufficiency Canada. March 01 2012 13:02. Posts 7290 | Profile Blog # |
On March 01 2012 12:38 gunman103 wrote:
Show nested quote +On March 01 2012 12:14 DimmuKlok wrote:
I too feel that we should push for a lynch on day one. Mafia has nothing to lose with with a no lynch on day one, where the town loses the potential for more information with a lynch. That's why it's crucial that everyone posts their opinions on topics and stays active so we can get reads on everyone.
I agree. However, we will lose our number advantage more rapidly if we do lynch someone just for the sake of lynching. If there's no potential for information to be gained by lynching him, then we should not do so.
No. We are better off to RL lynch someone. Town typically cannot kill players, so RL every day is required unless it cannot be afforded.Last edit: 2012-03-01 13:02:36 |
| |
|
| EchelonTee United States. March 01 2012 13:04. Posts 3403 | Profile # |
On March 01 2012 12:57 Sufficiency wrote:
NVM. 9 townies 3 mafia. We got at least 2 free lynch.
don't edit!!!!!!!!
Seriously don't edit. Your words have to be set in stone, or you could just go back and edit whatever you want to be un-said. This is a warning.
I'll take this opportunity to invite everyone to re-read all of the rules carefully, please ^^Last edit: 2012-03-01 13:06:31 |
| | learn lots. dont judge. laugh for no reason. be nice. seek happiness. -D[9] || Na`Vi - LGD - Dignitas - Liquid - Fnatic |
|
|
| gunman103 United States. March 01 2012 13:05. Posts 84 | Profile # |
On March 01 2012 12:57 Sufficiency wrote:
How many townies do we have? We should random lynch if we have a free lynch.
9 townies, 3 mafia atm. Not very good odds for getting a mafia in a random lynch imo. We should play it smart and only lynch to get information or to kill mafia. Not just blindly hope to get a mafia by pure luck. |
|
|
| trackd00r Chile. March 01 2012 13:10. Posts 283 | Profile Blog # |
Suffciency, If you are willing to random lynch anyone, which player it would be? I hardly see a point of RL someone later on this day because we already might have better reads in that moment. If you want to take this action, throw a name by now. I don't really like the idea though.
Going to bed now. See you in about 9 hours. |
| | ''They put signs, but I can't read'' |
|
|
| Sufficiency Canada. March 01 2012 13:11. Posts 7290 | Profile Blog # |
On March 01 2012 13:04 EchelonTee wrote:
Show nested quote +On March 01 2012 12:57 Sufficiency wrote:
NVM. 9 townies 3 mafia. We got at least 2 free lynch.
Seriously don't edit. Your words have to be set in stone, or you could just go back and edit whatever you want to be un-said. This is a warning.I'll take this opportunity to invite everyone to re-read all of the rules carefully, please ^^
Sorry I didn't know. I won't edit anymore. |
| |
|
| gunman103 United States. March 01 2012 13:13. Posts 84 | Profile # |
On March 01 2012 13:02 Sufficiency wrote:
Show nested quote +On March 01 2012 12:38 gunman103 wrote:
On March 01 2012 12:14 DimmuKlok wrote:
I too feel that we should push for a lynch on day one. Mafia has nothing to lose with with a no lynch on day one, where the town loses the potential for more information with a lynch. That's why it's crucial that everyone posts their opinions on topics and stays active so we can get reads on everyone.
I agree. However, we will lose our number advantage more rapidly if we do lynch someone just for the sake of lynching. If there's no potential for information to be gained by lynching him, then we should not do so.
No. We are better off to RL lynch someone. Town typically cannot kill players, so RL every day is required unless it cannot be afforded.
I'm just saying that we should lynch people to get information. RL is fine if we have no suspicions to go on and it should be used as a last resort imo. I'm not opposed to RL, but there are better alternatives. |
|
|
| Sufficiency Canada. March 01 2012 13:15. Posts 7290 | Profile Blog # |
On March 01 2012 13:10 trackd00r wrote:
Suffciency, If you are willing to random lynch anyone, which player it would be? I hardly see a point of RL someone later on this day because we already might have better reads in that moment. If you want to take this action, throw a name by now. I don't really like the idea though.
Going to bed now. See you in about 9 hours.
I actually FoS gunman103 right now for suggesting no RL. |
| |
|
| Sufficiency Canada. March 01 2012 13:16. Posts 7290 | Profile Blog # |
Oh great. Now he is defensive about it.
Anyway, since it's not the time to vote yet, we might as well wait until everyone talked a few lines. |
| |
|
| Sufficiency Canada. March 01 2012 13:17. Posts 7290 | Profile Blog # |
| I also FoS OtoshimonoU for being a compromiser. |
| |
|
| gunman103 United States. March 01 2012 13:36. Posts 84 | Profile # |
| All I was saying is that we should use our lynches carefully. If you think that RL is better than actually thinking about who your going to lynch, what they said, and what information could be potentially gained by lynching them, that's your choice. |
|
|
| DimmuKlok United States. March 01 2012 13:48. Posts 194 | Profile # |
| We shouldn't need to worry about a RL and I don't see the point in discussing one. Even if we don't have a solid case on someone after the first day, we would be better off lynching a lurker than someone at random. Mafia would love to not have to contribute. |
|
|
| Tiystus United States. March 01 2012 13:51. Posts 5 | Profile # |
| No-lynching should be out of the question. If there is an RL, that is sad but necessary if we cant make any cases against anybody. |
|
|
| friedchicken United States. March 01 2012 13:51. Posts 142 | Profile # |
The way I see it, if we don't do a day one Lynch, the mafia kills one of us. If we do a lynch, the mafia kills one of us and we get a chance to kill one of them. There is the chance that we'll lynch one of our own, but if we do, at least we get some info.
Lets lynch someone. |
| | "Don't panic" - The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy | |
|
|
| Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 Next All |
|
Store
