[WCS EU] Season 1 Finals -…
[SPL] Round 5 Week 3 Revie…
[GSTL] Week 10 - Prime Tim…
[WCS KR] Innovation vs. Sy…
[WCS AM] Ro16 Group D Prev…
TL Site Changes
[WCS EU] Grubby, MMA, Ret …
Pizza: All Tiers Reached
Vici and RisingStars Advan…
Up&Down groups for 2013 WC…
HerO, Revival Interviews -…
[SPL] Round 5 Week 4 Start…
Get 50% off Papa John's pi…
TL Advertising Features
UK Soldier beheaded in L…
McDonald's 'supporting' …
YouTube Thread
Dating, how's your luck?
[\m/] Heavy Metal Thread
The Automated Ban List
Roxin's Starcraft II Strea…
TL Site Changes
DC/VA/MD Weekly Nerd Dinne…
Ask TL Staff Anything
IMMvp Fan Club
The Stephano fanclub
[Stream} rebOrn
[Stream] Deanyo
[H] Computer hangs
Computer Build Resource Th…
Simple Questions Simple An…
The Ultimate Mouse Thread
Bad Internet Signal Strength
GomTV: about the gamespe…
IdrA signs with eMG
Awesome/Confusing SC2 BM
Designated Balance Discu…
Match Making Rating Tool
Grandmastering the Ladde…
[GSTL] NSH vs MVP 2013 S1
[WCS EU] Finals Day 1 Prem…
Overclock.net $2,500 SC2:H…
FREE 64 Player Knockout: S…
Ottawa's Got Game! Estimat…
[G] [D] Parting's PvP Prol…
The HotS Zerg Help Me Thread
[G] The MAN Train: Immorta…
[Q] Is Mech weaker then bi…
The HotS Terran Help Me Th…
[M] (2) Oasis 9
Map Jam & Challenge #5
[M] (4) Eureka
Work In Progress Melee Maps
Map Analyser Tool
DotA 2 Team Recruitment …
Inhouse Dota
The International Intera…
General Discussion
Dota 2 QQ thread
Dota 2 funny pics thread
[D2L] Fnatic vs. Mouz
[G-1] LAN Finals
Starladder Season 6
Dota 2 General LR thread
Merita $250+ Australian Do…
Simple Questions, Simple A…
[G]uide to Lifestealer
Question: Luna Item Build
Newly ported Hero discussi…
[G] In-Game Dota Guide for…
2 Artificial Intelligenc…
[D] New BW Server
sGs New Player/Low Level…
Map (4)Kyanite Prospect …
[Update] itemBay SSL Gra…
TeamLiquid Legacy Starle…
D Ranks Teamleague Season 4
[TLS2] Results and Standings
[GC S3] Gambit's Cup Semif…
Gambit's Cup Season 3 Roun…
C Ranks Teamleague Season 1
Simple Questions, Simple A…
Increasing APM/EAPM
Practice Partner Thread
Challenger map on Starcraf…
Champions League/Europa …
NBA Playoffs 2013
War Thunder - Come check…
TL MMA Pick'em Pool 2013
UFC 160: Velasquez vs Bi…
[T] Bastard "Mini" Mafia!
[M][N] Les Mafia
Les Mafia Voting Thread
The Injuries Thread
General nutrition recommen…
Running Thread
Leta - Movie
Michael - skyline
Anytime - Beast
By.Hero - Shuttle
Anytime - Pusan
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads


IRC Web Chat

TeamSpeak 3 (96 users)


Active: 7738 users

[DYESL] Summer Season -Edmonton Open-

Forum Index > StarCraft 2 Tournaments
 
 DYEAlabaster   Canada. June 03 2012 15:49. Posts 992
Profile Blog # 
[image loading]
Thanks to Chris Steele for this awesome Poster!

-HYPE VIDEO-


DYESL Summer

The DYESL Summer Season is finally announced!

Many changes are going to be happening this season, including restructuring, administrational changes. I have dry-tested some of these features, but will explain in detail what they will be below.

The venue is not changing! We love Overklocked Gaming & Computers and plan on working with them for a long time! Information for Overklocked can be found here:

The Entrance Fee for Tournaments is set at $30/event. Given the amount of gaming that you are getting, along with the on-site barcraft, this seems a fair price! For people concerned about the price, please read over All the information, and then contact me!

Structure Changes:

Code S:
+ Show Spoiler +

Code X:
+ Show Spoiler +

Map & Prize Pool For Code S/X:
+ Show Spoiler +

Code A:
+ Show Spoiler +

Time Between Games:
+ Show Spoiler +

Organizational Procedure:
+ Show Spoiler +


IMPORTANT INFORMATION REGARDING CODE S QUALIFIERS
READ THIS IF YOU WANT TO BE IN CODE S


+ Show Spoiler +

Dates for the Summer Season Tournaments are being finalized right now, but expect there to be at least 1 tournament in June, July, August, and September (before school). The July or August tournament will include a ticket to MLG Raleigh.

Cheers!
~Discover Your Energy
Last edit: 2012-06-04 06:34:38
 
Old Post

 
 DYEAlabaster   Canada. June 03 2012 16:04. Posts 992
Profile Blog # 
Reserved for Results!
 
Old Post

 
 Gofarman   Canada. June 04 2012 05:20. Posts 503
Profile # 
Overall I really like the changes, things look good. Of course though I have some questions and figured here was as good a place as any. (In decreasing order of importance).

____________________________________________

Code S
last paragraph;


DYEAlabaster wrote:
The other change is as follows: In order to reduce wait time, the winner of each group will be seeded into a round robin group, where the first place will be seeded into the grand final, second place seeded into the lower bracket final, and third/fourth seeded to the lower bracket semi-final.


I was hoping you could explain this further as I don't really get what portion of the bracket you are referring to with this segment.
____________________________________________

Prize Pool

DYEAlabaster wrote:
Prize Pool:
1st- 50%
2nd- 25%
3rd- 10%
4th- 5%
5/6- Money Back

You show the % of the prize pool that players will be cutting out of (in Code S) but there is no reference to the amount that could be attributed to the prize pool per player. With the set up that I am used to there is 'generally' a 10$ amount of the buy-in to admin/venue costs and assuming a large event (60 people) the prize pool would be 1280$ =(16*25)+(44*30)
+ Show Spoiler [theoretical distribution] +
I would also like to note that the prize for 5/6th should be better defined as you do have more then one buy-in (prepay for code S is 25)
Keep in mind that the prize pool is complete theory and just described to illustrate a point, I have no idea the actual break down for the buy-in -> prizepool. (I would love that to be defined though)
____________________________________________

Online Qualifiers
Lastly I have a couple questions about the Online qualifiers and the prepay.

You mention that there may be a third qualifier with would reduce the number of places that each qualifier would award. Firstly how/when would you determine if a third qualifier is required?

In the case of the third qualifier being required what criteria would you use to choose the wild card position AND it seems like alot of games will needed to played out extra to ascertain the line at 5/6th place in case of the third qualifier.

I would also like to voice some assumptions I am making when it comes to the Qualifiers that should be addressed in the main post. Firstly you make no mention of the style of the tournament although the bracket on Challonge is labeled a double elim bracket, so I am assuming that is correct. I am also assuming bo3's throughout the qualifier with random seeding.
____________________________________________

Map Pool

DYEAlabaster wrote: Maps-
ESV Cloud Kingdom LE (Strategy)
ESV Ohana LE (Rush)
GSL Daybreak (Standard)
GSL Metropolis (Macro)

The starting map for each set will be a rotation of the non-strategy maps. In other words...

I like the idea of a smaller map pool for Code S & X; with that said I have a possible concern and a 2 Questions about it.

1. Why don't you start rounds on Cloud Kingdom?
2. In the finals Bo5 or Bo9 how will you determine the map order?

With such few maps (and no rule to the effect) in a bo3 players will be repeating maps if no rule is set to avoid that. (obviously in a Bo5 or greater there will be no avoiding repeats.) This IMO is not optimal.
____________________________________________

Barcraft

DYEAlabaster wrote:
If you wish to come only for the Barcraft Segment, then it will cost $5 for the night and include a concession item. This means that you will be paying OKG only a few dollars for a night of Barcrafty fun! If you participate in the tournament, you will not be charged if you choose to stay and watch.

This implies that you are renting the entire facility, is this true or am I free to come and play other games while the tournament is going on? ie. are you telling me there is a 5$ entry fee?
____________________________________________

I would like to finish all this off with a Kudos and congratulations, You are portraying the image of progress and that is a step in the right direction.

PS- You never said how potential admins might contact you about achieving the position.
 
Old Post

 
 Gofarman   Canada. June 04 2012 05:21. Posts 503
Profile # 
Hope that wasn't too TLDR for the rest of you, issues should be address publicly since we have seen how shit goes when it is left to private individuals to adjust shit.

GLHF I'm gonna wreck some shit.

oh, I forgot to mention my question about prepay for those top16 qualified. Deadlines for when you will replace unpaid people and what means they should use to pay.
Last edit: 2012-06-04 05:23:12
 
Old Post

 
 DYEAlabaster   Canada. June 04 2012 06:33. Posts 992
Profile Blog # 
I was hoping you could explain this further as I don't really get what portion of the bracket you are referring to with this segment.

In regular MLG style, the winner of each group gets seeded into a winners semi-final. Instead of doing that, The winner of each group will be seeded into a Winner's Round Robin. The seeding will work identically to how MLG seeds their winners- third fourth go into the loser's semifinal, second goes into the loser's final, and first goes onto the grand final.

I hope that clears up any confusion. The only reason for the RR is so that first place finishers have less wait time between matches


____________________________________________

You show the % of the prize pool that players will be cutting out of (in Code S) but there is no reference to the amount that could be attributed to the prize pool per player. With the set up that I am used to there is 'generally' a 10$ amount of the buy-in to admin/venue costs and assuming a large event (60 people) the prize pool would be 1280$ =(16*25)+(44*30)
+ Show Spoiler [theoretical distribution] +
I would also like to note that the prize for 5/6th should be better defined as you do have more then one buy-in (prepay for code S is 25)
Keep in mind that the prize pool is complete theory and just described to illustrate a point, I have no idea the actual break down for the buy-in -> prizepool. (I would love that to be defined though)

5/6 will have $30 returned to them, regardless of what they paid to play
$10 from every ticket will be used to pay venue. $17 from every ticket will be used for the prize pool (in the case of $25 tickets, $2 will be added to keep consistency. $3 from every ticket will be used to help keep the events running, as before.
17*60= 1160.
However, your theoretical distribution is correct- In the case of "weird' numbers (128, 64, they will be rounded to the nearest number divisible by 5)

____________________________________________

Online Qualifiers
Lastly I have a couple questions about the Online qualifiers and the prepay.

You mention that there may be a third qualifier with would reduce the number of places that each qualifier would award. Firstly how/when would you determine if a third qualifier is required?

In the case of the third qualifier being required what criteria would you use to choose the wild card position AND it seems like alot of games will needed to played out extra to ascertain the line at 5/6th place in case of the third qualifier.

I would also like to voice some assumptions I am making when it comes to the Qualifiers that should be addressed in the main post. Firstly you make no mention of the style of the tournament although the bracket on Challonge is labeled a double elim bracket, so I am assuming that is correct. I am also assuming bo3's throughout the qualifier with random seeding.

Qualifiers will be just as you stated- edited that into the main OP b/c I forgot to mention it, thanks.
I would like to, ideally, have an even number of qualifiers played, b/c that will eliminate much of the problems that you outlined. If 4 are run, top 4 are decided in a DEBracket, which would reduce the number of games necessary.

____________________________________________

Map Pool

DYEAlabaster wrote: Maps-
ESV Cloud Kingdom LE (Strategy)
ESV Ohana LE (Rush)
GSL Daybreak (Standard)
GSL Metropolis (Macro)

The starting map for each set will be a rotation of the non-strategy maps. In other words...

I like the idea of a smaller map pool for Code S & X; with that said I have a possible concern and a 2 Questions about it.

1. Why don't you start rounds on Cloud Kingdom?

"Strategy" Maps are those that require a different playstyle, and, while well designed maps, are inherently unbalanced. Crossfire is an excellent example of what happens when a Strategy Map overstays its welcome. I choose to not start on CKLE because of its role in the map pool. It is very obviously different, will require off-beat strategies, and will be played in a manner unlike any other maps (or at least, it should). I personally believe that Strategy maps should NEVER be forced to be played, but only chosen if somebody has made the effort to run through all the intricacies it holds.

Any random player who is moderately good at the game can "pick up and play" the three "regular" maps having never seen them before. However, in order to play CKLE well, you should have something special prepared. It's because of this belief that I think no Strategy maps should be 'forced' play. Obviously it will be played (alot) because many people understand it. However, the precedent I want to set for future tournaments is that strategy maps will be cycled out the fastest. and will truly reward players for innovative thinking and dedication.

I would have no chagrin starting on CKLE at present because of the ubiquity of the map. However, in future tournaments, if 'new' or other Strategy maps are implemented, then they will hold the same place as CKLE. Expect to have the "regular" maps for quite a while, but Strategy maps will only stay 1 season (at most). Once a strategy map is "figured out" it quickly heads down imbalance road and turns into fuck-this-map street.


2. In the finals Bo5 or Bo9 how will you determine the map order?
The For the finals, the Players will take turn picking map order, starting with the winner's bracket player.
Repetitions will only be allowed once you run out of maps.
For instance- Saro vs MK
Saro picks CKLE
MK picks Ohana
Saro picks Metro
MK picks Daybreak
Saro picks Ohana
-------------------------
MK picks CKLE
Saro picks Metro
MK picks Daybreak
Saro picks CKLE

The line denotes the separation b/w bo5 and bo9
Great question, thanks!


With such few maps (and no rule to the effect) in a bo3 players will be repeating maps if no rule is set to avoid that. (obviously in a Bo5 or greater there will be no avoiding repeats.) This IMO is not optimal.

A ruling about not repeating maps in a bo3 has been written in, thanks for the clarification.
____________________________________________
This implies that you are renting the entire facility, is this true or am I free to come and play other games while the tournament is going on? ie. are you telling me there is a 5$ entry fee?

As before, the Red Room will be reserved for "walk-ins". In the past, people wishing to come and spectate have been able to do so for free. With the optimization of casting, watching, and playing, however, a $5 surcharge does not seem to be too much to ask, especially given a free concession item. All remaining revenue will go to OKG (if you buy a $3 chocolate, OKG will get $2 back from it.
____________________________________________

I would like to finish all this off with a Kudos and congratulations, You are portraying the image of progress and that is a step in the right direction.

PS- You never said how potential admins might contact you about achieving the position.

Info Edited into OP.

Thanks!
Your concerns have really helped clarify alot of things ^^

Last edit: 2012-06-04 06:33:21
 
Old Post

 
 Gofarman   Canada. June 04 2012 08:22. Posts 503
Profile # 
Thanks for the response, I still have a couple things I'd like to point out as they weren't addressed by you in your reply or were unclear.

How would you like a potential admin to contact you?

Could you give a practical example of how the Code S Round Robin System is going to work, it seems very ambiguous still. I understand the MLG bracket idea and as of yet I don't get how yours achieves what it is intended while saving time.

As for you defining the maps in certain roles that seems fine while IMO inaccurate for the maps you dictated in the roles. The idea of having limited turnover in the map pool is good and if this is where you start I'm all for it.


PS- if you intend to have each 'horizontal' part of the championship bracket be a Round Robin group I would like to let you know that by doing that you eliminate the reward from winning the previous group and it would be actually beneficial for players to just lose all the games in the previous group 0-2 so that they can go into the champ bracket fresh. I might be wrong, but I just thought maybe that was your intention.
 
Old Post

 
 Andro   Canada. June 04 2012 08:53. Posts 81
Profile # 
Edmonton starcraft! cant wait :D
Old Post

 
 Fusik   Canada. June 05 2012 13:15. Posts 5
Profile # 
As sick as this would be to go to, am I going to get my play time worth of cash? I payed last time for the tournament, and for the day pass being told I would be able to game or practice while waiting. That didn't happen.

I waited 2.5 hours to play a game. Once I started I left the computer for a second to use the washroom, while in party with my opponent and someone unhooked all my stuff and started to play on the computer in the middle of my BO3. When I said something, I was told to fuck off, ect, ect.

If i remember correctly I was pretty high in my group. 2 matches left to the finals or semi in code X (that was for the gold and plats right?) or something. Waited another few hours till about midnight and came up, explained the situation, told there was nothing to be done, so I just left. We were that large group (about 5 people) who came to chat with you. I have you on skype and if bringing stuff up like this private is what you want then I would gladly do that.

Tbh and not looking for people to feel sorry, the last tournament was one of the reasons SC2 fell off for me. After finishing school and spending my two weeks before starting FT at work again practicing hard for the tournament, just to get up and leave because nothing was managed was a let down. If I can't go to a hometown tournament with 128 people or whatever it is, why try to go pro in something? How is dreamhack or MLG with 1000's of people managed? Do I wait till Sunday to play. I know there is exaggerating, it's just how I felt at the time.

Now for the lazy people!

TL;DR

Nick is a pretty straight forward honest guy. He's pretty cool and has been working and reworking this tournament for everyone around. Tbh if I can get my ass off Diablo 3 and LoL, I may get back in practice and attend this, though last time I really played was the end of February. If i am not attending I wish the best of luck to everyone who goes, and let everyone know about the new experience. I wish the best!
Success without honor is an unseasoned dish; it will satisfy your hunger, but it won't taste good. - Joe Paterno
Old Post

 
 Andro   Canada. June 08 2012 18:08. Posts 81
Profile # 
Saturday, June 8 at 6pm hmmm ima take it you mean june 9th and 10th

and fusik im sure youll get at least what you put in, nicks tounrys last alll day long

also from my experience no one in the edmonton community would say fuck off after you try to tell them that they stole your computer >< who was it?

the last tourny was a quickly thrown together thing from nick that he was honestly considering just canceling but since the community said they wanted it regardless of the quality he went forward with it, the ones before that allt ran extremely well becides a hiccup here or there.


Old Post

 
 DYEAlabaster   Canada. June 09 2012 11:08. Posts 992
Profile Blog # 

On June 05 2012 13:15 Fusik wrote:
As sick as this would be to go to, am I going to get my play time worth of cash? I payed last time for the tournament, and for the day pass being told I would be able to game or practice while waiting. That didn't happen.

I waited 2.5 hours to play a game. Once I started I left the computer for a second to use the washroom, while in party with my opponent and someone unhooked all my stuff and started to play on the computer in the middle of my BO3. When I said something, I was told to fuck off, ect, ect.

If i remember correctly I was pretty high in my group. 2 matches left to the finals or semi in code X (that was for the gold and plats right?) or something. Waited another few hours till about midnight and came up, explained the situation, told there was nothing to be done, so I just left. We were that large group (about 5 people) who came to chat with you. I have you on skype and if bringing stuff up like this private is what you want then I would gladly do that.

Tbh and not looking for people to feel sorry, the last tournament was one of the reasons SC2 fell off for me. After finishing school and spending my two weeks before starting FT at work again practicing hard for the tournament, just to get up and leave because nothing was managed was a let down. If I can't go to a hometown tournament with 128 people or whatever it is, why try to go pro in something? How is dreamhack or MLG with 1000's of people managed? Do I wait till Sunday to play. I know there is exaggerating, it's just how I felt at the time.

Now for the lazy people!

TL;DR

Nick is a pretty straight forward honest guy. He's pretty cool and has been working and reworking this tournament for everyone around. Tbh if I can get my ass off Diablo 3 and LoL, I may get back in practice and attend this, though last time I really played was the end of February. If i am not attending I wish the best of luck to everyone who goes, and let everyone know about the new experience. I wish the best!


I completely understand your sadness and frustration over the tournament format, iirc your group was the one that was most affected by the disorganization, and I apologize.

Because of what happened at that tournament, this tournament has some very severe differences!

Code A now has several reserved computers, and will be starting cocurrently with Code X (with Code S delayed slightly)
Code A now has 4 different game styles, which basically comes down to the idea that people will no longer be waiting on SPECIFIC players, but can get up and play with anyone, at any time. Because of the necessary organization of Code S/X, the different available styles of games for Code A allow people to snake in games here and there without waiting on specific players. Got some time before your next RR game- why don't you grab a friend and play a "Funday Monday" game? Got a group of 4 people, play a 2v2, etc ^^

Finally, even if there is some downtime between games, being at the lan will be a much more friendly environment. There will be 2 streams constantly running games on the two large TVs, with couches, food, and such in an organized manner that it will resemble a Barcraft. Want to take a break from playing games? Grab a couch, order some food, and watch the best players duke it out. Want to try your hand at casting? Well, one of the streams will be a "casting couch" style stream, meaning that anyone can come in and cast!

With the less strict progression of Code A, more out-of-game activities, and a greater Barcraft feel, you will be guaranteed to get a whole day of play, and not be boring with waiting a little between games. That being said, you will never be asked to wait more than about 45 minutes, unless you want to.

There will also be 2 Code A specific Admins that will work directly with you guys to make sure no issues like this time happens again! Hope this helps
 
Old Post

 
 DYEAlabaster   Canada. June 09 2012 11:16. Posts 992
Profile Blog # 

Thanks for the response, I still have a couple things I'd like to point out as they weren't addressed by you in your reply or were unclear.

How would you like a potential admin to contact you?

PM, Skype (Nicholas.Siennicki)

Could you give a practical example of how the Code S Round Robin System is going to work, it seems very ambiguous still. I understand the MLG bracket idea and as of yet I don't get how yours achieves what it is intended while saving time.

Working on an explanation video for you guys, but basically- you get first place finishers from each group play in a round robin instead of a winners semi-final. It doesn't save time, just gives first place finishers something to do while waiting.

As for you defining the maps in certain roles that seems fine while IMO inaccurate for the maps you dictated in the roles. The idea of having limited turnover in the map pool is good and if this is where you start I'm all for it.

CKLE is a strategy map, meanwhile being pretty figured out. In the future, different strat maps will be used, but for now, I am going with the 'go to' standard strat map

PS- if you intend to have each 'horizontal' part of the championship bracket be a Round Robin group I would like to let you know that by doing that you eliminate the reward from winning the previous group and it would be actually beneficial for players to just lose all the games in the previous group 0-2 so that they can go into the champ bracket fresh. I might be wrong, but I just thought maybe that was your intention.

It's just like the MLG format... the better you place in RR, the better you get seeded in the champ bracket.
 
Old Post

 
 Gofarman   Canada. June 09 2012 14:27. Posts 503
Profile # 
Ahhh, I see.

So just the top1 from each group will be placed into the Round robin group.

I would be interested to see if the past top finishers would like to have this since it will guarantee that they will play the same top level opponents an additional time. I'll see if I can get some opinions on the matter and get back to you.
 
Old Post

 
 Gofarman   Canada. June 09 2012 15:19. Posts 503
Profile # 
I hear there is a qualifier tonight?

I thought they were on (as posted above) Saturday and Sunday this weekend.
 
Old Post

 
 DYEAlabaster   Canada. June 09 2012 16:01. Posts 992
Profile Blog # 

On June 09 2012 15:19 Gofarman wrote:
I hear there is a qualifier tonight?

I thought they were on (as posted above) Saturday and Sunday this weekend.



There was a large crowd today, so I threw together a quali, like i said I would.

Qualified Players-

Shooter
YogyBear
Kowdbuff
SteelZealot
 
Old Post

Please log in or register to reply.
 
Refresh
StarCraft: Brood War
StarCraft 2
Dota 2
[ Show 94 non-featured ]

» Recent SC2 Results
» Premier SC2 Tournaments

The Little App Factory