On July 02 2012 07:46 austinmcc wrote:My vote is currently on mK. However, for anyone uncomfortable with their current lynch candidate, I'd suggest taking a look at
drwiggl3s. Seriously.
The Good Doctor's filter is the following:
(1)
Show nested quote +On June 30 2012 12:14 drwiggl3s wrote:Hi all. First game + first post playing mafia so bare with me.
On June 30 2012 11:28 NoSmurfHere wrote:I'm not kidding, my role PM is like "you're a
Role Name.".
Let's kill this guy:
On June 30 2012 10:12 mKmKmK wrote:
On June 30 2012 10:06 NoSmurfHere wrote:
I am a Role Name.
how quaint.
vague post is vague...
My role PM also said I'm a "Role Name". So NoSmurfHere is definitely town in my books.
As has been mentioned, the OP had the "role name" bit, and we can assume if scum got a VT fakeclaim it had the same text. Role name wasn't indicative of mK's alignment, not indicative of the Good Doctor's alignment either.
(2)
The ol' ninja vote BKE.
(3)
Nine hours later
Show nested quote +On July 01 2012 05:13 drwiggl3s wrote:
Ok since some people asked, here's what I'm thinking.
I agree that BKEXE's initial posts were a tad scummy. But what gave it away to me was that after casualman voted for him, both Mattchew and BKEXE immediately returned the favour and voted for casualman to be lynched. Both without any explanation other than saying "Wtf is this". And then later, both went MIA for quite a while instead of explaining their votes or trying to defend BKEXE.
You may ask why would casualman throw his vote at BKEXE so early. It could be he is either just noob, or it could be he read BKEXE as scum (like many people are now) but just before a lot of people had the chance to.
As for other players: I find many people are soft defending BKEXE and in their posts trying to put suspicion onto others (with little reason). I see these as scummy moves.
Stop and read that third post. Please. The only post of any substance. The Good Doctor thought BKE looked scummy, but didn't mention that and didn't vote for BKE. However, after CASUALMAN of all people voted for BKE, BKE and Mattchew voted for casualman with little explanation. This makes BKE scum in drwiggl3s head.
Here is how casualman voted, by the way:
Show nested quote +On June 30 2012 14:23 casualman wrote:
I love to bandwagon. Being a newb, I can read nothing from these posts and will blindly trust in authority figures. Woohoo!
##Vote BroodKingEXE
Either casualman is trolling and trolling hard, or casualman just dropped a vote that legitimately should make every go "Wtf is this?" That's
a legitimate response to casualman's comment and vote. BKE's wtf is this vote for casualman is the tipping point that makes drwiggl3s read BKE as scummy and vote him, which is a terrible reason given casualman's post and vote.
I don't necessarily read casualman as scummy yet, but drwiggl3s also drops a little explanation for why casualman dropped his stupid post.
Show nested quote +
You may ask why would casualman throw his vote at BKEXE so early. It could be he is either just noob, or it could be he read BKEXE as scum (like many people are now) but just before a lot of people had the chance to.
What is this? Seriously. What is this? Everyone reads casulman's post as trolling or stupidity, and here is drwiggl3s
trying to defend another player's nonsense post without prompting. WHY is he doing this? Moreover, how in the world do you get "He might be new or he might have read BKE scummy before others did" out of casualman's post?
Finally, I have to point this out. Because I think drwiggl3s is lying.
Show nested quote +On June 30 2012 12:14 drwiggl3s wrote:
Hi all. First game + first post playing mafia so bare with me.
Show nested quote +On July 01 2012 05:13 drwiggl3s wrote:
As for other players: I find many people are soft defending BKEXE and in their posts trying to put suspicion onto others (with little reason). I see these as scummy moves.
I don't know about you guys, but I did a lot of lurking here before playing. drwiggl3s makes sure to tell us it's his first game, but then his only post of substance is describing why BKE looks a little scummier because people are SOFT DEFENDING BKE. That's not a "This is my first day cycle playing mafia" thought in my mind. That's not my thought process in the first thing I ever post. Either casualman is lying about not being a smurf, or casualman got fed that reasoning by scumbuddies. I actually lean towards the former, because casualman created his account 5/1/2012. Fresh account + "Oh I'm a newb, bear with me" + comments about soft defense = lying about being new in my mind.
***NEW ADDED POINT*** - anyone who thinks that drwiggl3s is ACTUALLY new is going to have to be convinced that him saying he's new outweighs the soft defense reference as well as the fact that he just happened to name himself drwiggl3s and joined mrwiggles' game. Does the naming thing not make others think smurf over new player?
tl;dr
- drwiggl3s ninja voted
- drwiggl3s later gave an AWFUL reason for his ninja vote that makes no sense
- drwiggl3s randomly props up casualman's ridiculous post
- drwiggl3s does not appear to be as new as he claims
- drwiggl3s hasn't really contributed anything helpful at all
- drwiggl3s is scum
I am currently voting mK. I am alright with my vote on mK. But the one player I'd absolutely be willing to swap to, or to try and get others to swap to, is drwiggl3s
Store
