Website Feedback
Closed Threads
IRC Chat irc.quakenet.org #teamliquid
IRC Web ClientTeamSpeak 3 (60 users) | |
|
| xNSwarm August 02 2012 12:48. Posts 146 | Profile # |
On August 02 2012 12:38 Roflhaxx wrote: Show nested quote +On August 02 2012 12:24 xNSwarm wrote: On August 02 2012 10:13 redviper wrote: On August 02 2012 09:29 Coagulation wrote: On August 02 2012 09:08 Leporello wrote:The problem with that is consciousness. Make a copy my brain and upload it to a body, and that's great, but my consciousness is still sitting right here. Transferring my actual consciousness, from my brain to an external vessel, seems like the most impossible kind of sci-fi. Not that this project is really any bit better. Even if you preserve my brain, there are natural aging processes that will still occur. Senile robots, everywhere.
thats not exactly accurate. physics dictates in order to make an exact copy of something it has to be destroyed So you would not remain after the process of transferring yourself.
Since when does physics dictate that? What physical law are you quoting here?
If you want to make a perfectly exact copy of something you need to copy it down to the quantum realm. For example, If there is a photon at point a and you want to make a copy at point b you can't just put a photon at point b. The second photon also needs to have the exact same spin and other features. The only way to do this is through quantum entanglement, which scientists have done over very long distances. To create the copy, you first need to find out the state of the original by measuring it. However, the act of measuring a particle that small actually changes the state of the initial particle. In short, the original isn't "destroyed", but the state's of all the particles that make up it are altered enough where physicists would consider it to be much different from the copy of the unmeasured original. So you would never end up with 2 exact copies of the same thing. I haven't done much physics so some of this may not be right.
I am pretty sure that wouldn't apply to this, however I do not think we will be a able to make a copy of someones consciousness until far into the future, if you think about how the brain works, it would not be like copying a hard drive. More like copying RAM or something, and we would also have to learn the brains "language" the thing there is how do even know if 2 different brains speak the same "language". There might be small differences between person to person.
Its going to be a very long time until scientists are able to exactly copy a cubic centimeter block of wood. There is a lot of information in that amount of space. Considering the comparison between a piece of wood and a human brain, copying a brain isn't very realistic for an extremely long time.
|
|

|
| Tarot Canada. August 02 2012 12:51. Posts 324 | Profile # |
On August 02 2012 12:45 xsnac wrote: Show nested quote +On August 02 2012 12:43 DarkwindHK wrote: On August 02 2012 12:36 xsnac wrote:it will fail . there is absolutely no way anything can read our thoughts . http://2045.com/ : C point will fail and this is why : no one and nothing will ever be able to read and understand how our neurons hold information , and what kind of information it holds . ofc we know what they are made of , but how they hold information we will never know .
You can already play World of Warcraft with just your Brain...... While the reaction time is still a bit slow, with better technology it will improve.
im not saying you cant do stuff only with your brain . i say they cant copy paste our brain into a hard disk . like they said on C point : artificial brain with human personality . cuz they can never understand how neurons hold information and what kind of information they hold .
Don't know why you would think that they can never do that, considering they already can decipher simple words from monitoring brain activity. Still a long way to go but nothing so far indicating that its impossible. |
|

|
| plogamer Canada. August 02 2012 12:52. Posts 837 | Profile Blog # |
On August 02 2012 11:49 LunarC wrote:People seem to be ignoring the whole endocrine system. You are your body just as much as you are your brain. Show nested quote +On August 02 2012 11:47 plogamer wrote: The whole human species is a gigantic brain.
As we grow more connected and learn to share ideas better, our species gets more advanced. Our minds live on forever in this gigantic brain.
Doesn't anyone else see it?
Human Instrumentality?
No idea about Human Instrumentality. I googled it, got some Evangelion stuff about melding all minds into one.
My idea is like how each neuron is connected to another in the brain. Our brains are connected to other brains in a collective consciousness.
As neurons fire off and strengthen their connections with eachother, so do our brains connect with other brains. Chaos theory, I suppose. A smaller pattern repeated on a much larger scale. As we develop language - speech, text and then better means to use the language - printing press, telegrams, telephone, internet etc., our brains act like neurons that are strengthening its connection to others.
But the main idea is to separate from the idea of an 'individual' mind. Again, if a mind is composed of thought patterns - knowledge, ideas, experiences, etc.etc., then sharing these thoughts continue that portion of the mind in another brain.
This might not satisfy someone who clings to the 'individual'. But even the 'individual' mind is not static. We forget things, we learn things. When I pass down all my knowledge and if none of it is accepted, then that knowledge is no different than having been forgotten by the collective consciousness. Or perhaps my knowledge is outdated and gets over-written, as would be the case if I the 'individual' learned something different about a topic I had known prior. |
| | <3 Polt <3 Stephano <3 Hero <3 DeMuslim <3 Scarlett |
|

|
| vult United States. August 02 2012 12:53. Posts 611 | Profile Blog # |
this reminds me of Fallout 3. lets hope Earth isn't a smoldering asteroid by then. |
| | "U sixpoll?" -aLive, in NASL Showmatch vs IdrA (http://youtu.be/Ff1znFPWNCk?t=33s) |
|
|
| masterbreti Korea (South). August 02 2012 12:59. Posts 2547 | Profile Blog # |
So wait, My body can become a machine. I wonder if we can custom order out machine in advance.
I know just what mine will look like
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/XJy1Q.jpg) |
| | Playing sc2 in Korea! Twitter: radrelsc |
|
|
| GhostLink Spain. August 02 2012 13:13. Posts 399 | Profile # |
I don't understand one thing. How can the idea of immortality be foreign and scary to you if you have never experienced death? Answer this!
and yeah, at all costs, definetely |
| | The world's still the same. There's just less in it. |
|
|
| Ettick United States. August 02 2012 13:13. Posts 1558 | Profile Blog # |
| Considering how much technology has changed in the last 30 years, I think that something like this being around by 2045 is possible. |
| | Do you really think people would do that? Just go on the internet and tell lies? |
|
|
| JimSocks United States. August 02 2012 13:22. Posts 764 | Profile # |
| its just a copy, its not really us. |
|
|
| snowbird Korea (South). August 02 2012 13:22. Posts 1968 | Profile Blog # |
The stuff on 2045.com reads like a preamble to an awesome movie
...but then the avatars began to develop a mind of their own, so we created an underground resistance and travelled back in time to... wait
Last edit: 2012-08-02 13:22:42 |
| |
|
| GTPGlitch August 02 2012 13:23. Posts 2091 | Profile Blog # |
This is a terrible idea -.-
Where is the joy in life if it never ends? |
| |
|
| FlyingToilet United States. August 02 2012 13:29. Posts 731 | Profile # |
Doesn't all energy just fade away? so what are they making energy that doesn't expire that u can use to intake for your own personal benefits, i don't think this would ever exist let alone i would never wanna watch everything just go away anyways...
Back to topic lol, i guess i would want for a imitation of me for others to remember i mean who wouldn't want to have a statue of yourself and be forever remembered in ancient Greece  Last edit: 2012-08-02 13:32:01 |
| | http://justin.tv/flyingtoilet |
|
|
Liquid`Jinro Sweden. August 02 2012 13:35. Posts 32587 | Profile Blog # |
On August 02 2012 07:53 zalz wrote: Show nested quote +On August 02 2012 07:46 Yoshi Kirishima wrote: hey guys, we all know that the longer people live, the more the earth becomes populated...
But what if we actually find good planets and travel and live there? We have the entire universe. We could live forever (or a really long time) while not overpopulating a planet. Either find a way to travel really fast and/or freeze people during the trips :D (or if we're immortal, 30 or some years travelling shouldn't be thaaat bad... right? kekek)
If we can't go faster than light, all of this is pretty pointless. Even at light speed the universe is too big for us to properly get around. Sure, you have generation ships, where people live and die on ships in order for their offspring to reach a planet, but just imagine the logistical horror. Think about you and your class, or friends, or colleagues. Do you happen to have any nicknames? Inside jokes? Slang that only you use? Now imagine how language would develop if you put people on a ship and set them on an 80 year voyage where they have no contact with earth, thus no way to maintain their language. Even if we use generation ships, the colonies would not even have humans that speak any language known on earth. Unless you force them to adhere to strict linguistic lessons and execute anyone that invents a new word. Nah, if we can't find a way to go faster than light speed, we are pretty screwed.
That's silly, there's no way - especially given the amount of media they would carry with them - that English (or any other language) would evolve into a completely new language, neither here on earth or in the confines of their ship.
I doubt the difference would even be that of current english compared to 1700s. |
| | tell the guy that interplanatar interaction is pivotal to terrans variety of optionitudals in the pre-midgame preperatories as well as the protosstinal deterriggation of elite zergling strikes - Stimey n Formerly FrozenArbiter |
|

|
smokeyhoodoo United States. August 02 2012 13:49. Posts 1021 | Profile # |
On August 02 2012 13:23 GTPGlitch wrote: This is a terrible idea -.-
Where is the joy in life if it never ends?
Is the thought that you're going to die one day the only thing that gives you joy? That is the only scenario in which your statement makes any sense. |
| |
|
| CaptainSlow Malaysia. August 02 2012 13:52. Posts 161 | Profile # |
On August 02 2012 12:59 masterbreti wrote:So wait, My body can become a machine. I wonder if we can custom order out machine in advance. I know just what mine will look like ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/XJy1Q.jpg)
HAHA agreed
But seriously, havent you watched all those sci fi movies? nothing good ever comes out of research like this. If it can even be done. whcih is why i voted for "never will exist" |
|
|
| ThaZenith Canada. August 02 2012 14:18. Posts 3046 | Profile Blog # |
Ideally, immortality would come in the form of being able to just live forever, as a normal human.
The idea of your brain being transplanted into a robot sounds good to me, since it's still 'you'.
The idea of your brain being 'copied', and you're programmed into a robot. That's scary. Imagine, after the procedure, talking to the robot that is a copy of you. That just highlights that you're still going to die, there's just someone else who says he's you now. The shift in perception required to see 'data' of you as being you is a tremendous leap.Last edit: 2012-08-02 14:19:58 |
|
|
| Nymphaceae United States. August 02 2012 14:34. Posts 343 | Profile Blog # |
I feel like this is more of like one of those mass suicide kool-aid cults.
If you had the ability to move your mind from yourself to a machine, but your body died as you did this. How can you prove that you just didn't clone your mind into the machine, and kill yourself? |
|
|
| GwSC United States. August 02 2012 14:51. Posts 1723 | Profile # |
On August 02 2012 14:18 ThaZenith wrote: Ideally, immortality would come in the form of being able to just live forever, as a normal human.
The idea of your brain being transplanted into a robot sounds good to me, since it's still 'you'.
The idea of your brain being 'copied', and you're programmed into a robot. That's scary. Imagine, after the procedure, talking to the robot that is a copy of you. That just highlights that you're still going to die, there's just someone else who says he's you now. The shift in perception required to see 'data' of you as being you is a tremendous leap.
That's sort of the problem I have with this also. Still though, if I knew I was about to die it would be nice if I could have the piece of mind that an exact copy of myself, same personality/ideas/thought processes etc would carry on what I was doing in life/finish whatever I didn't get a chance to. Last edit: 2012-08-02 14:59:51 |
|
|
| daemir Finland. August 02 2012 15:06. Posts 3759 | Profile # |
This whole thing is like directly out of Alastair Reynolds' book series "Revelation Space" which I found quite enjoyable scifi and it goes through a lot of what's come up in this topic so far, like copying or moving someone's self into a hologram, is it really them then? Memory problems, travel through to stars with low tech.
and I'm pretty sure I'd go insane at some point if I were to live forever.Last edit: 2012-08-02 15:25:14 |
|
|
| SimoNostalgia United States. August 02 2012 15:08. Posts 72 | Profile # |
I am actually for it.
I wonder what religion would think. "This world is meant to die, So that we can live again with God" Is what they would say |
| |
|
| Millitron United States. August 02 2012 15:17. Posts 1224 | Profile Blog # |
Immortality is a bad thing. Our mortality is an essential part of what it is to be human. Without mortality, time has no value. An immortal would easily outlive his memory. 300 years from now, you will have forgotten all your triumphs and failures from your youth; you will have forgotten who you were.
This is a fact. The human mind can only remember so much. How much do you remember from Kindergarten, and how accurate do you think those memories are? Not much, right? And what little you do remember is probably pretty skewed by now. Well if you're immortal, that will eventually happen to every moment of your life. You'll eventually forget your entire childhood. You'll forget your wedding. You'll forget the births of your children. Essentially, all these moments become meaningless and forgotten. I wouldn't want a life like that. |
| |
|
| Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Next All | | |
|
|
| |
|
Sidebar Settings...

|