EDT 19:18 CEST 01:18 KST 08:18

Streams: 121 live
50426 total viewers

Active: 8225
Pizza Meter
[WCS KR] Innovation vs. Sy…
[WCS AM] Ro16 Group D Prev…
G-1 Champions League LAN F…
[WCS KR] Ro4 Preview / Cod…
[WCS AM] Ro16 Group C Prev…
Pizza: All Tiers Reached
Vici and RisingStars Advan…
Up&Down groups for 2013 WC…
HerO, Revival Interviews -…
[SPL] Round 5 Week 4 Start…
viOLet forfeits WCS AM due…
FXOpen acquires Seed from …
Get 50% off Papa John's pi…
TL Advertising Features
Iron Man 3
UK Soldier beheaded in L…
Best way to "move on" af…
Should people be allowed…
The Big Programming Thread
Happy Birthday GMarshal!
The Automated Ban List
Presenting Store 2.0
Calgary Barcraft - MLG Spr…
TL.net Ten Commandments
Naniwa FanClub!
The Avenge Fanclub
[Stream]Cereal
[Stream] BCNMusic
Simple Questions Simple An…
How to put build order ove…
Computer Build Resource Th…
The Ultimate Mouse Thread
What mouse/pad does your f…
IdrA signs with eMG
WCS AM - Ro16 Interviews…
Pizza: All Tiers Reached
Montage - Shingeki no Zerg
Starcraft 2 Science: Ski…
Official State of the Ga…
[WCS AM] RO16 Group D Prem…
[Code S] Ro4 Day 2 WCS Kor…
[WCS AM] RO16 Group C Prem…
[WCS EU] Challenger League…
ChoboTeamLeague - Season 4
[Q] Is Mech weaker then bi…
The HotS Protoss Help Me T…
CatZ CC first counter - a …
Simple Questions Simple An…
[G] TheCore - Advanced Key…
[A] Starbow
Map Jam & Challenge #5
[M] (4) Artika World
Work In Progress Melee Maps
TeamLiquid Map Contest Fin…
G-1 Champions League LAN…
General Discussion
Dota 2 QQ thread
The International Intera…
DotA 2 Team Recruitment …
Bruno Community Q&A
Perfect World's Dota 2 Su…
[The International] Easter…
MN Dota 2 Tournament
[D2L] EG vs. Na'Vi & VP
Starladder Season 6
[G] In-Game Dota Guide for…
[H] Night Stalker
Simple Questions, Simple A…
[G] Clockwerk, The Offlani…
[G]uide to Lifestealer
DES Sonic Interview 5/18…
iCCup Area Bans? (why n…
[D] New BW Server
2 Artificial Intelligenc…
Nada's Body
[Update] itemBay SSL Gra…
D Ranks Teamleague Season 4
Gem League II
[GC S3] Gambit's Cup Semif…
C Ranks Teamleague Season 1
[SRT] Ro16 Group B
Increasing APM/EAPM
Practice Partner Thread
Challenger map on Starcraf…
Simple Questions, Simple A…
Android: Netrunner
EVE Corporation
World of Tanks
Dungeon Crawl Stone Soup
NBA Playoffs 2013
[Patch 3.07: Nerf Everythi…
The Shikyo Memorial for QQ…
Anyone Diamond want to joi…
[LCS] All-Star Tournament
[OGN] Olympus The Champion…
[LoL] General Stream Thread
[Champion] Nunu
[Champion] Cho'Gath
[Resource] Champion Tips &…
The: What is my item worth?
Barbarian - Builds/Discuss…
[G] Hardcore
[M][N] Les Mafia
Newbie Mini Mafia XLII
[T] Bastard "Mini" Mafia!
Questions & Answers
The 2013 Weightlifting Pro…
Running Thread
Leta - Movie
Michael - skyline
Anytime - Beast
By.Hero - Shuttle
Anytime - Pusan

Website Feedback

Closed Threads

IRC Chat
irc.quakenet.org #teamliquid

IRC Web Client

TeamSpeak 3 (92 users)

Steam Blocks Class Action Lawsuits with ToS Change

Forum Index > General Forum 1 2 3 4 5 All
 
 YoureFired   United States. August 02 2012 07:21. Posts 730
Profile Blog # 
If you were like many other Steam users who logged on this morning to play some games before work or as a daytime activity, you saw that Valve recently updated their Terms of Services and required a new acceptance in order to use their Steam cloud video game service. However, what caught my eye about this one was a bold-type font regarding a new "Section 12" that read:


SECTION 12 CONTAINS A BINDING ARBITRATION AGREEMENT AND CLASS ACTION WAIVER. IT AFFECTS YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS. PLEASE READ IT. IF YOU LIVE OUTSIDE OF THE UNITED STATES, SOME OR ALL OF SECTION 12 MIGHT NOT APPLY TO YOU.


I, personally, was a bit hesitant to accept the terms without reading them fully, and I found several articles that filled me in on the details.

http://www.joystiq.com/2012/08/01/valves-updated-steam-subscriber-agreement-bars-class-action-law/


If you're like most people, when Steam started up this morning you noticed there was an extra pop-up prompting you to click a button that says "I agree" a few times, and you did this without reading much into what you were consenting to. Turns out you don't actually "own" your left hand anymore. Oh, well.

Actually, it was an updated Steam Subscriber Agreement altering the legal options available to customers. First, Steam customers may no longer bring class action claims against the service, mirroring similar moves by large distribution and publishing companies, including Sony and Microsoft.

"We considered this change very carefully. It's clear to us that in some situations, class actions have real benefits to customers," Valve explains. "In far too many cases however, class actions don't provide any real benefit to users and instead impose unnecessary expense and delay, and are often designed to benefit the class action lawyers who craft and litigate these claims."

Individual claims will still be allowed, though Valve has now instituted a required process that channels these claims to arbitration or small claims court. Valve will reimburse the cost of arbitration under a certain amount, provided the arbitrator deems the claim isn't frivolous nor the expenses unreasonable.

Valve is also opening an office in Luxembourg "to better serve our EU customers and partners," who will sign an EU-specific SSA.

Hey, at least you still own your left hand.


So, do you think Valve is overstepping their bounds here by banning users from joining together in class action lawsuits? Or do you believe that they have a legitimate point, that class action lawsuits rarely benefit the individuals, and that individual claims will still be processed and recompensed?


EDIT woops poll mixed around yes and no, adding new one
Poll: Should companies stop users from joining class action lawsuits?

No, they help protect user's rights (144)
 
57%

No, but I trust Valve not to abuse this power (82)
 
32%

Yes, they rarely ever help out the individual (27)
 
11%

253 total votes

Your vote: Should companies stop users from joining class action lawsuits?

(Vote): No, they help protect user's rights
(Vote): No, but I trust Valve not to abuse this power
(Vote): Yes, they rarely ever help out the individual


Last edit: 2012-08-02 07:27:09
Carpe natibus
Old Post

 
 Troxle   United States. August 02 2012 07:25. Posts 481
Profile Blog # 
I already have my gripes and issues with Valve...I think this was yet another step in the wrong direction for them.
If you're homophobic, you're probably ugly, so don't worry about a gay guy coming onto you. - jarrydesque
Old Post

 
 BuddhaMonk   Canada. August 02 2012 07:29. Posts 672
Profile # 
I agree with their statement that many class action lawsuits are brought forth by lawyers for the purpose of making themselves money and without much regard to actually helping consumers.

However, this type of clause is probably unenforceable. None of your poll answers address this opinion.
Last edit: 2012-08-02 07:29:47
Old Post

 
 laegoose   Russian Federation. August 02 2012 07:33. Posts 211
Profile # 
Imagine people do class action lawsuit and judge says "lol you've selected a checkbox on the internetz no lawsuits plzkthx". Does it work like that?
Last edit: 2012-08-02 07:34:58
Old Post

  GnarlyArbitrage   August 02 2012 07:55. Posts 575Profile Blog # 
Unless Steam stole from me, used my credentials in a illegal way, or do anything illegal, they are still bound to the U.S. Law, no matter what the fuck has been signed.

Can you get someone to sign something allowing you to kill them, and then not get charged with murder? Nope.
Old Post

 
 Shai   Canada. August 02 2012 08:03. Posts 553
Profile Blog # 
I looked up the legality of this in Canada, and it isn't legal in at least 4 provinces, untested in the other 6. This was specifically tested in British Columbia and the supreme court supported the individual's right to sue, either as a class action or otherwise.
A case could be made for "a deistic god, a sort of god of the physicist, a god ... who devised the laws of physics, god the mathematician, god who put together the cosmos in the first place and then sat back ..." - Dawkins
Old Post

 
 gubbstrut   Sweden. August 02 2012 08:04. Posts 38
Profile # 
Agree to terms online by checking a box is about as binding as signing a document without having to show ID, theirs no proof its something you did.
Old Post

 
 carrion   United Kingdom. August 02 2012 08:15. Posts 83
Profile # 
lawyers making rules which will be disputed so they can make a living arguing about them. I despise bureaucracy.
Old Post

 
 Excludos   Norway. August 02 2012 08:19. Posts 2189
Profile Blog # 
God I love that so many people think "class action lawsuit" is the same thing as any lawsuit. You can actually ban class action lawsuits with the tolaa class action lawsuit, legally, in the ToS. You can not ban "suing Valve", as so many seems to think.
Last edit: 2012-08-02 08:22:00
"Factional balance means little when genius is at hand" - choboPEon
Old Post

 
 Integra   Sweden. August 02 2012 08:23. Posts 4927
Profile Blog # 
Legal rights being made illegal through a digital contract. I think you actually could sue valve for this.
"Dark Pleasure"
Old Post

 
 Demonhunter04   August 02 2012 08:28. Posts 1470
Profile # 
Would Valve be allowed to include a statement in the ToS forbidding individual claims as well? Just curious about how far they can go with this sort of thing. The article makes it seem like they chose to allow individual claims.
"If you don't drop sweat today, you will drop tears tomorrow" - SlayerSMMA
Old Post

 
 sAsImre   August 02 2012 08:28. Posts 2980
Profile Blog # 
class action doesn't exist here...
Last edit: 2012-08-02 08:30:49
Old Post

  motbob   United States. August 02 2012 08:32. Posts 11467Profile Blog # 
I wonder how much consumers actually benefit from class action lawsuits. From what I've seen, payouts are always rather meager. Would love to see the breakdown of payouts (amount paid by the corporation / amount paid to lawyers / amount paid in legal fees / amount paid out to consumers)
<marttorn> lucky I don't live in a culturally diverse place
Old Post

 
 Thenerf   United States. August 02 2012 08:35. Posts 254
Profile # 
Terms of Service is not a legally binding contract. Also a judge can ignore a legally binding contract.

This is pretty obvious and the courts do notice these tactics and ignore them.
Every atom in your body was forged in a star. Quit being a pussy.
Old Post

 
 Probe1   United States. August 02 2012 08:38. Posts 16445
Profile Blog # 
Well if it turns out to be an abusive tactic to screw customers I'm sure that we can petition for legislation to remove it. I'm not going to pitchfork them until they actually do something terribly wrong.
우정호 KT_VIOLET 1988 - 2012 While we are postponing, life speeds by
Old Post

 
 Rybka   United States. August 02 2012 08:38. Posts 469
Profile # 
My theory, for what it's worth:

One only need look at the at the almost commonplace attacks against credit card databases, and the recent attack on the Sony/Playstation Network online service, as proof that breaches are a real threat.

As DotA 2 ramps up in popularity, the amount of personal data they hold will grow. This personal data includes credit card information. Yesterday, I saw 65,000+ people online for DotA2, and it will grow from there. People will go after their database - they went after Sony. Think about it, why else would there be a class action lawsuit against Valve? It's not like they're going to release some bad software update that frags everyone's computers.

In fact, haven't they been breached once before, ie Gabe's apology letter? (Source needed ofc).

IMHO Valve is smart to head this off at the pass, but they could probably go about it a better way, such as specifying in plain language "class action lawsuits related to data theft and breaches of security even when best practices for electronic security have been followed."

Strange update though... a little extreme. Such is the world we live in, I suppose. Either way, Valve still has my trust and respect. This won't stop be from using Steam or purchasing their games and services.
"Leoric is one of the most heroes around." -Qbek
Old Post

 
 sAsImre   August 02 2012 08:41. Posts 2980
Profile Blog # 

On August 02 2012 08:38 Rybka wrote:
My theory, for what it's worth:

One only need look at the at the almost commonplace attacks against credit card databases, and the recent attack on the Sony/Playstation Network online service, as proof that breaches are a real threat.

As DotA 2 ramps up in popularity, the amount of personal data they hold will grow. This personal data includes credit card information. Yesterday, I saw 65,000+ people online for DotA2, and it will grow from there. People will go after their database - they went after Sony. Think about it, why else would there be a class action lawsuit against Valve? It's not like they're going to release some bad software update that frags everyone's computers.

In fact, haven't they been breached once before, ie Gabe's apology letter? (Source needed ofc).

IMHO Valve is smart to head this off at the pass, but they could probably go about it a better way, such as specifying in plain language "class action lawsuits related to data theft and breaches of security even when best practices for electronic security have been followed."

Strange update though... a little extreme. Such is the world we live in, I suppose. Either way, Valve still has my trust and respect. This won't stop be from using Steam or purchasing their games and services.


they'd never say that because they can't know for sure that the bold part will be true.
They don't need to get a high tiers decision to have bad security (ala Sony) but inviduals error can be enough and you don't want to be sued because one of your employees screwed up big time.
Old Post

 
 Rybka   United States. August 02 2012 08:48. Posts 469
Profile # 

On August 02 2012 08:41 sAsImre wrote:

Show nested quote +



they'd never say that because they can't know for sure that the bold part will be true.
They don't need to get a high tiers decision to have bad security (ala Sony) but inviduals error can be enough and you don't want to be sued because one of your employees screwed up big time.


Well said.
"Leoric is one of the most heroes around." -Qbek
Old Post

 
 Felnarion   August 02 2012 08:55. Posts 362
Profile # 
It's unenforceable. You can't make someone give up their ability to join a class action lawsuit.

It's really simple logic. By bringing up a class action lawsuit, the plantiffs are asserting Valve breached some kind of agreement, or harmed them in some way. How can Valve enforce a contract that, in all likelyhood, the plantiffs would be asserting they had broken? Makes no sense.
Old Post

 
 Craton   United States. August 02 2012 08:55. Posts 10179
Profile Blog # 
I doubt this clause is even legally enforceable.
jeongmal kkeutnangeongayo (mari eoptneyo) eonjena geuraetjyo || LoL 2350+ Jungler || KPop: http://cratonz.minus.com/uploads
Old Post

1 2 3 4 5 All
Please log in or register to reply.
 
Refresh
StarCraft: Brood War
StarCraft 2
Dota 2
[ Show 102 non-featured ]

» Recent SC2 Results
» Premier SC2 Tournaments
Sidebar Settings...

The Little App Factory



The opinions expressed by our users do not reflect the official position of TeamLiquid.net or its staff.

Advertising | Jobs | Privacy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren. Ad tag: TF_US.
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2002-2013 Teamliquid.net. All Rights Reserved