|
Ahahahahah WOW the turnout is soooo good! This is gonna be more epic than a wow raid! when do we start?!
Btw Chuiu think you forgot the rule about ppl not being able to edit their posts, even for grammar corrections.
And a Q: If you're a plain towny and announce that you are one, there's no disadvantage there, yes? Since the mafia already know who all the mafias are.
|
This thread is very likely to be closed and Chuiu will start up another one for Mafia Game #2. It's so much simpler that way.
|
Woah! 10 pages to catch up after not reading for a day! My brain just fizzled reading all the accusations, theorycrafts and posts people have posted I'd like to reserve comments on anyone as of now (there's just too many people to guess from - so I'm starting off with people's hunches as of now, but they're just hunches, and therefore pointless (as of yet) to jump in the bandwagon).
Anyway, on to the mayoral candidates. I think Ace's bodyguard plan is real spiffy and seems failsafe. As he and alot of others have said (but alot more people seem inactive -_- ) we need a startup plan ASAP after a mayor is chosen to at least know 100% we have an efficient Townie mayor. And from then on we work the ground up on the clues.
I would have hoped there's a list of all the candidates and their reasons and plans as to why to they should be elected mayor, since looking back at how the first game went, we really need an efficient (and preferably experienced) mayor.
For now my vote goes to Ghar.
But again, whoever it is that becomes Mayor, I think if we dont have any other plan, we MUST make sure to at least carry out the Bodyguard Plan.
|
On March 19 2008 07:25 fusionsdf wrote:
suspicioussss....empy edited post!
|
Quoted from bottom of page 35
|
Oh and if people are wondering why that's suspicious, last game someone actually wrote to reveal his role and left it for like 5mins and then edited it out. Who knows, maybe there was something in that empty quote or maybe there wasnt. But its all the way at the bottom of page 35 as the last post...so maybe it had something..idk lol too much reading to do!
|
On March 19 2008 09:09 Kau wrote:Show nested quote +On March 19 2008 09:02 Ace wrote:On March 19 2008 08:57 Kau wrote: Ace:
About your Bodyguard plan, what stops a mafia mayor from pming each actual bodyguard with a list that is something like:
mafia 1 mafia 2 mafia 3 bodyguard #
Each actual bodyguard would get a pm back from each of the fake mafia-bodyguards and they wouldn't know.
Then once the mayor gets checked by a detective, couldn't there be fake mafia-detectives that state that the mayor is innocent? They can't because all the other Bodyguards that didn't get a PM would know something is wrong. In the event that they do that, it just helps the town because we can just apply all clues and DT/Jack power to that list of suspects and catch the Mafia asap. No fake detective is going to spring forward and state the Mayor is innocent because they run the risk at having a real detective also step forward and once again we are back to place where we have confirmed a situation with at least 1 suspect as Mafia (because someone is lying) and a sure fire Mafia lynching. What I'm saying is that the pm is sent to every real bodyguard. Say there are 3 bodyguards. 3 pms would be sent out: Mafia 1 Mafia 2 Bodyguard 1 Mafia 1 Mafia 2 Bodyguard 2 Mafia 1 Mafia 2 Bodyguard 3 Each bodyguard would then get pms back from Mafia 1 and 2 and thus are "confirmed". And about fake detectives springing forward and stating the mayor is innocent, the townies have no way of knowing who is telling the truth and who isn't. We can't know when a real detective steps forward because he could very well be fake.
WOW. This is a big flaw in the DT plan -_- And I dont see any way we can go around it if we have a mafia major. We need to seriously rethink what the mayor's backup plans are gonna be in his first 100 days in office!
I'm starting to have suspicions with Ace, because despite his sound arguments right up to this post, he's persistent in that this flaw isn't even there (if Im correct from what I've read of his posts) :O
And to the person that suggested the idea that we a detective should come up, WHO would the brave soul be? And we have no way of verifying it's true! (Unless more detectives come up..but that would be plain stupid).
Though it seems its the most solid plan we have now, having to lose even one DT for this plan...The worst case scenario is that the mafias have taught out a real good plan to mess this up and we're not seeing it...Bah I dont even know if Im making much sense now...better reread some posts again.
|
Lol oh k thx guys. Musta missed those posts >_<
|
Lol really it's unfortunate inControl got lynched, but it was just pure rotten luck. I bet if inc was Mafia everyone would be cheering for Ace right now, despite it being of pure luck. I'm just really worried Mafia's already a couple of steps ahead of us. One with a Mad Hatter down, two with Mayor being roleblocked, and three the possibility that Ace is mafia after all *shudders*. But anyway, congrats to you and randombum for getting the mayoral position and the pardoner.
I hope the other blues are paying attention to whats going on generally, especially the Jack. You've got a pretty powerful role there.
Well, at least town seems to have cooled down abit from the junk posts and waiting for night now.
|
Necromancer: The necromancer has the ability, once every ten turns, to bring one of the dead back to life. A clue will be left behind pointing to his identity.
Or something like that.
10 turns?
EDIT: removed useless extra quotes
|
Seriously i hope ppl DONT SEND IN THEIR PMS YET TO ACE! for the plain and simple fact that we dont even know hes clean yet. wait a DT confirms. if all the blues send in their pms (or a number of them), and ace turns out to be mafia, we're as good as dead!
Ok, time to sleep. It's 4AM and I gotta wake up at 7 for a full day of experiments >_<
|
On March 21 2008 04:57 Scorch wrote:Show nested quote +On March 21 2008 04:43 Fishball wrote: Like I said, Day hasn't even come yet, nor did any Detectives are able to check Ace yet. It's kinda pointless having arguments when things didn't even happen yet. Detectives ARE able to check Ace already. There's no timing restriction in the OP: Show nested quote +Detective - You have three abilities you may use. You have the ability to ask me, once per day/night cycle, whether or not a specific clue points to a specific person and get a yes/no answer. You have the ability to, twice a game, ask me what role a specific person has. And for the last ability you may ask me how many mafia voted to lynch a specific person (cannot use this on mayor election). You may only use one ability per day. The fact that no Detective has yet stood up yet claiming to have found Ace a mafia member indicates that, in fact, Ace is townie.
O rly? What if they havent had the time to post yet or somein? Like inControl? That would plain suck ay.
|
Lol well if i were to put myself into a DT's shoes, there's 3 other DTs, and i might think hey maybe the other DTs are gonna post so i dont have to. plus the fact that because we have no way verifying that the DT is a real blue until we lynch him, it really isnt much motivation for any DT to step up as of yet. And if i remember correctly, if the DT who steps up claims youre mafia, we lynch him to make sure hes telling the truth? Lol but yeah I dont see any other way right now, but its just not very encouraging for the poor DTs.
|
Lol I guess I didnt think of that point. But idk, Im just saying its possible. I mean hey some of them may not have posted at all, and may want to stay longer in the game. plus theres the whole which-DT-should-tell-the-info since the DTs dont know each other. But watever man, I just seriously really hope a true DT comes up and proves your clean. That'll do us some morale boost lol
|
On March 21 2008 05:31 Ace wrote: they wont say it publicly. If no DT steps up, I'm obviously innocent. Lol ok fingers crossed on that then. Come day phase and non steps up then i wont suspect you anymore
|
Aww I missed this! lol i was quite busy >_< well congrats to the town and Ace! Let's see whos next up the chopping deck!
|
Urgh there's just too many pages to catch up on but seriously the kills are way to accurate....and despite whatever everyone is saying I'm having a bad feeling about Ace again lol.
|
Lol I gave up trying to follow this game around more than 100pages back. There's just too much to keep up with...especially if you miss checking up even for a day. Plus alot of useless posts and bickering (from the ones that I saw previously...i dunno how its been for the recent 100pages tho). Anyway good luck with it guys. Though townies dont seem to be doing much good
|
|
|
|