EDT 18:13 CEST 00:13 KST 07:13

Streams: 137 live
55994 total viewers

Active: 12028
Pizza Meter
[WCS AM] Premier League Ro…
TI3 East Qualifier Preview
[WCS AM] Challenger Round …
StarLadder Season Six Prev…
[SPL] Round 5 Week 3 Previ…
Papa John's explores EG, L…
TeamLiquid Map Contest Fin…
Liquid wins the Curse Invi…
mousesports defeats DD.Dot…
Dragon joins Clarity Gaming
Code S Group of Death, Par…
Axiom.Miya Retires
New Get 50% off Papa Joh…
TL Advertising Features
[TV/BOOK] *SPOILERS* Gam…
GeoGuessr geography game
Anime Discussion Thread
Should people be allowed…
[TV] HBO Game of Thrones
The Automated Ban List
Oklahoma tornados may 20th…
Long Island, NY BarCraft!
Ask TL Staff Anything
The Team Liquid Book Club
The IdrA Fanclub
MvP_DongRaeGu Fan Club
[Stream] KumA
Stream LoLvsxD
Any fix for Twitch tv lag?
Computer Build Resource Th…
Mechanical Keyboard Guide
Requesting any recent expe…
Help me to buy an ultrabook
Why are people against P…
I made a timezone indepe…
Papa John's explores EG,…
GM / Master map hacker a…
SC2 Ranks (site)
Grandmastering the Ladde…
[WCS AM] RO16 Group A Prem…
[SPL] Team 8 vs. KT Rolste…
[SPL] Samsung KHAN vs. EG-…
Revive Your Energy Starlea…
Ritmix RSL gNations
The HotS Protoss Help Me T…
The HotS Terran Help Me Th…
[D] Best Hold Immortal sen…
[G] Going CC-first Bio in …
[G] TheCore - Advanced Key…
[D] Map Contest Finalists,…
TeamLiquid Map Contest Fin…
Some questions about the m…
[M] (2) Lycan Hills
[D] Map Maker's Show
General Discussion
The Defense Season 4 ann…
TL's Item Trading Thread.
Dota 2 QQ thread
The International Intera…
G-1 League LAN Finals An…
[TPL S5] Demon Edge Cup
[D2L] Na'Vi vs. Dignitas
Starladder Season 6
[The International] Easter…
Sticky Flames Weekly Dota …
Solo Mid - Who? What? How?
A guide to Krobelus, the D…
Simple Questions, Simple A…
Newly ported Hero discussi…
[Guide] Storm Spirit by Bl…
Better Server Registry F…
[Update] itemBay SSL Gra…
snipealots 24/7 afreeca …
Making an Online Broodwa…
Pucca Comeback?
[TLS2] Qualifier #4 VODs
[GC S3] Gambit's Cup Semif…
Torenhire Starleague II
[TLS2] Qualifier #4
2x Speed Hack Perversion T…
Defiler Tour #57 [75$]
Challenger map on Starcraf…
Simple Questions, Simple A…
Tips and tricks: Defilers …
Practice Partner Thread
RollPlay -- D&D Campaign…
2012 - 2013 Football Thr…
Tera MMORPG
FIFA Thread! (PC - Xbox …
Path of Exile
[Patch 3.07: Nerf Everythi…
[Stream] Mondays with Monte
[HELP] i CAN'T play melee …
[LoL] General Stream Thread
[D] Pro Scene Evolution
[OGN] Olympus The Champion…
[Guide] Montegomery's Supe…
[Champion] Nunu
[Champion] Udyr
D3 Hardcore Community
The: What is my item worth?
Witch Doctor Discussion
[M][N] Les Mafia
Doctor Who Mafia Voting th…
Doctor Who Mafia
Running Thread
TL Health and Fitness Init…
The 2013 Weightlifting Pro…
Leta - Movie
Michael - skyline
Anytime - Beast
By.Hero - Shuttle
Anytime - Pusan

Website Feedback

Closed Threads

IRC Chat
irc.quakenet.org #teamliquid

IRC Web Client

TeamSpeak 3 (80 users)

[GG] Team Liquid Mafia - Resurrection - Page 11

Forum Index > TL Mafia 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62
 
 zeks   Canada. December 15 2008 16:01. Posts 1055
Profile Blog # 
"posting a screenshot doesn't prove anything. Isn't that right, shallow[bay]?" - Ver

in regards to scaramanga's screenshot

from what i see the screenshot is kinda cut off so we can't see ur name on the top left - seems like the img was resized for some reason


http://i255.photobucket.com/albums/hh125/scaramangaa/lol.jpg

i think its fishy that this supposed dt picked Ver of all people to check: i dont really see many strong clues against him, and i dont think anyone has posted an analysis on him thus far...

if what ace says is truth, then:
1. this dt lucked out (or is super smart) and picked Ver out of all ppl to check (20% chance to land a red)
2. this dt must have some sort of bond with ace previously for him to trust Ace right from the get go


i agree with ver, quit bandwagoning blindly
Last edit: 2008-12-15 16:04:39
"Two roads diverged in a wood, and I-- I took the one less traveled by, And that has made all the difference."
Old Post

 
 Scaramanga   Australia. December 15 2008 16:01. Posts 7613
Profile Blog # 

On December 15 2008 15:49 Ver wrote:
To start off, it seems more than a little strange that I'm being targeted without having made a single post. My reasons for that are below, but all the same, even if a DT followed what Ace suggested in the thread, there is very little reason why that DT would not check Ace himself as he is at least as dangerous/helpful as me if not even moreso. Lastly, why would the DT pm Ace of all people to be his mouthpiece, given that if he's mafia he's one of the most dangerous/the most dangerous person in the game and you don't want to give him a big head start by knowing a DT. He cannot know both that I am mafia and Ace innocent this early. Thus either this 'DT' is being really stupid or there is a greater scheme going on here.

The fact that everyone is taking this accusation at face value and bandwagoning me does not show a healthy minded town. I got accused out of nowhere and only one person questions these proceedings. Everyone is just bandwagoning from one target to another on the flimsiest of reasons. Killing Folca for last game is just dumb. Clues on day 1 are not a sufficient reason to kill Scar, but at the same time, posting a screenshot doesn't prove anything. Isn't that right, shallow[bay]? Then people voted for some random zombie who can equally be a clueless mafia or clueless townie. And now everyone jumps on me once I'm 'supposedly' guilty. As if anything can be proven this early. Quit the bandwagoning (folca->scar->veno-> me all in 1 day seriously lol) and think critically. Only 1 person so far is even questioning what's going on and everyone just dismisses him.

This would normally be a battle of arguing/my word vs Ace's. However, the fact that he say's he was informed I was a mafia from someone else makes this considerably more complex than a kill one then kill the other if wrong situation. Consider the two likely scenarios:

1) I am mafia, Ace and the DT are legit. Lynching me straight up is best case scenario.

2) I am innocent, and either Ace or the 'DT' are mafia. Here lynching me immediately puts us in a big hole. Ace can of course call out the 'DT' as mafia, but Ace could easily be mafia yourself fingering an innocent person. Or the mafia member posing as 'DT' could argue to get Ace killed. Thus the town gets considerably behind and either loses two of it's most valuable thinkers for 1 mafia (great great trade for them) or loses 1 analyst for 1 mafia, which is still a pretty poor trade for the town considering mafia KP is rounded up.

The point is that except for option 1 the town is going to be stuck in a very messy situation that will take several days to extricate fully and could potentially result in myself and Ace both being innocent and dying from the town itself. Or just as bad, I turn up innocent, Ace as mafia gets the town to kill the DT who didn't check Ace first and wastes two days of lynching again. Or Ace can prioritize his survival and kill the DT in the night. If you blindly rush the gun here you are betting on the fact that I am mafia and are way behind if I turn up innocent.

Thus I propose an offshoot of Alventenie's plan from game 3. Let us both live. Force the mafia to make a decision of who to kill. Unlike in Alventenie's plan, I cannot offer anything more than being a townie. But I am an exceedingly valuable townie in my analyses and plans, as the inner circle people last game can attest to (which is likely why I was fingered for this). And also analysis/plans are very easy to check on to see if I uphold myself logically as I consistently have before. If I don't hold myself accountable to this, then bam dead. The same goes for Ace and the results of this 'alleged' DT too.

Therefore, give us an extension till tomorrow to figure out a better target BC. I can stay up for an hour or so to debate but then I must sleep.

Edit: Finished an incomplete sentence (added 'argue to get Ace killed. ' in paragraph 2) )




Sorry ver, heres how it goes, your gonna get lynched tonight and if you flip green/blue then i can vouch for ace and then we lynch the fake dt, we traded you for a mafia, the better situation is that you are mafia, then we have a hidden dt with someone to speak and we can set some shit up, anyhow your gonna get lynched first night


On December 15 2008 16:01 zeks wrote:
"posting a screenshot doesn't prove anything. Isn't that right, shallow[bay]?" - Ver

in regards to scaramanga's screenshot

from what i see the screenshot is kinda cut off so we can't see ur name on the top left - seems like the img was resized for some reason

i think its fishy that this supposed dt picked Ver of all people to check: i dont really see many strong clues against him, and i dont think anyone has posted an analysis on him thus far...

if what ace says is truth, then:
1. this dt must have some sort of bond with ace previously for him to trust Ace right from the get go
2. this dt lucked out (or is super smart) and picked Ver out of all ppl to check (20% chance to land a red)

i agree with ver, quit bandwagoning blindly




Its odd that right after we get a spot of good luck you come out of no where to help ver, you guys havent really helped each other so why are you comming out all of a sudden in defence?, i dont see whats wrong with this plan, we get either get 1 mafia and a dt with a mouthpeice or we get 1 mafia dead for 1 townie, i'll take either of these

if you want me to re screen im happy to do so

What i think is weird is that you tried previously to get people to continue to vote for me even though i have proved without a doubt that im a townie, then you come to attack a plan that gets us at least 1 mafia
Last edit: 2008-12-15 16:08:00
Flash rapes and pillages your [s]expos[/s] villages | "If you are going on a trip, where would you like to go?"
Old Post

 
 chaoser   United States. December 15 2008 16:02. Posts 5538
Profile Blog # 

On December 15 2008 15:55 Scaramanga wrote:

Show nested quote +



Dude honestly are you thick or not reading my post, if ver is green well then gw we lynch the fake dt and bam we've traded a mafia for a townie gj, if ver and this dt are both mafia then we get this dt to rolecheck someone else to get a townie web, if he dosent check then we lynch him, either way we get 1-2 townies or a web of people working together



first of all, don't call me thick, that's rude. secondly, as I WAS SAYING, they are not stupid enough to do that first option (the trade) and if they do the second option (ver IS red) there's no way for us to 100% know the dt and ace are NOT red.

Here, i'll spell it out for you. If ver is red, he's dead, we ask the dt to check someone else. he says he cheked and they are green/townie. now what? how do we check that what he said is correct? you're assuming he doesn't check but that's stupid and would play into what you just said it stupid. he would obviously say he checked.
Haven't you heard? I'm not an ex-progamer. I'm not a poker player. I'm not an admin of the site. I'm mother fucking Rekrul.
Old Post

 
 Camlito   Australia. December 15 2008 16:04. Posts 4036
Profile Blog # 
God not this again -_-.
sAviOr...
Old Post

 
 Vivi57   United States. December 15 2008 16:07. Posts 6440
Profile Blog # 

On December 15 2008 15:58 chaoser wrote:

Show nested quote +



see, that's the thing! even if you ARE mafia, they don't have to be legit! they could just be sacing you to gain oyur trust


Even then, one less mafia would be good for the town.

If nothing else, ace's post says that we need to carefully watch him to see who's side he's really on.

1. If Ver turns up mafia then we need to check out ace to make sure he's not sacrificing one of his own to gain a list of blues.

2. If Ver turns up green or blue, we need to get the name of ace's dt and decide if we want to lynch ace or his "dt"

Either way, it will give the town a direction, even if the clues aren't good on the next day
Flash hwaiting! Nal_rA forever!
Old Post

 
 Camlito   Australia. December 15 2008 16:12. Posts 4036
Profile Blog # 
and @ Ver, with the lackluster list of seasoned mafia players missing (plexa, bockit, mtf to name a few) your name sticks out as someone to search. I wouldn't be surprised if a DT checked you and told ace for some reason. Buttt even though they CHECKED you and told ace, it doesn't mean ace isn't mafia.

I either see it as ver is mafia and so is ace.
or ver is mafia and so is chaoser. (unless chaoser is just overthinking and trying to overargue things).
sAviOr...
Old Post

 
 MoRe_mInErAls   Canada. December 15 2008 16:13. Posts 1210
Profile Blog # 
Hey guys! Just letting you know I'm detective. I'll have the mafia killed in no time

Edit: sorry did i say killed, i mean found out
Last edit: 2008-12-15 16:14:17
Old Post

 
 chaoser   United States. December 15 2008 16:16. Posts 5538
Profile Blog # 

On December 15 2008 16:07 Vivi57 wrote:

Show nested quote +



Even then, one less mafia would be good for the town.

If nothing else, ace's post says that we need to carefully watch him to see who's side he's really on.

1. If Ver turns up mafia then we need to check out ace to make sure he's not sacrificing one of his own to gain a list of blues.

2. If Ver turns up green or blue, we need to get the name of ace's dt and decide if we want to lynch ace or his "dt"

Either way, it will give the town a direction, even if the clues aren't good on the next day



1) will probably happen
2) this probably WON'T happen cause it's too stupid an action if they are mafia (which is the only real reason they would lie.)

either way, 1 means we need to still be suspicious, or even more so until we can prove without a doubt that he is straight up blue. i'm on;y saying all this because of the bandwagoning which shows that people are very quick to trust people which is a BAD thing. think for yourselve goddamnit! or else we'll be like mindless lamb for the slaughter
Haven't you heard? I'm not an ex-progamer. I'm not a poker player. I'm not an admin of the site. I'm mother fucking Rekrul.
Old Post

 
 Scaramanga   Australia. December 15 2008 16:17. Posts 7613
Profile Blog # 
Voting is closed it seams, looks like ver is lynched, lets see how this plays out

Edit:

On December 15 2008 16:07 Vivi57 wrote:

Show nested quote +



Even then, one less mafia would be good for the town.

If nothing else, ace's post says that we need to carefully watch him to see who's side he's really on.

1. If Ver turns up mafia then we need to check out ace to make sure he's not sacrificing one of his own to gain a list of blues.

2. If Ver turns up green or blue, we need to get the name of ace's dt and decide if we want to lynch ace or his "dt"

Either way, it will give the town a direction, even if the clues aren't good on the next day


Yep so were gonna get the dt to check ace, i hope to fucking got ver is mafia
Last edit: 2008-12-15 16:19:43
Flash rapes and pillages your [s]expos[/s] villages | "If you are going on a trip, where would you like to go?"
Old Post

 
 Camlito   Australia. December 15 2008 16:19. Posts 4036
Profile Blog # 

On December 15 2008 16:16 chaoser wrote:

Show nested quote +




1) will probably happen
2) this probably WON'T happen cause it's too stupid an action if they are mafia (which is the only real reason they would lie.)

either way, 1 means we need to still be suspicious, or even more so until we can prove without a doubt that he is straight up blue. i'm on;y saying all this because of the bandwagoning which shows that people are very quick to trust people which is a BAD thing. think for yourselve goddamnit! or else we'll be like mindless lamb for the slaughter


If ver is actually mafia this bandwagon is justified. People can see something as good and agree with what ace found, it's not like they read the name of someone who posted and see "ACE" and just agree with him.
sAviOr...
Old Post

 
 decafchicken   United States. December 15 2008 16:20. Posts 15139
Profile Blog # 
hahaha i just realized this thread got moved to sports n games
FAIL
how reasonable is it to eat off wood instead of your tummy?
Old Post

 
 ketomai   United States. December 15 2008 16:23. Posts 2403
Profile # 
I agree with chaoser.

There's a chance that Ace or his DT is mafia, and because there is still this chance, it's not really worth it to lynch Ver. There's little gain from Ver flipping red because there's still a chance that he was used as a sacrifice, and that will keep the town from benefiting much from his death, even if he is a mafia. That, and the mafia killing power does not decrease with 9 mafia still alive.

Ver is one of the better thinkers of mafia. Sacrificing him, of all people, is a bad idea. Perhaps if it was an inactive or someone who didn't speak up much, it would be a good idea, but Ver could be a huge help for the town, and betting him for a less than sure benefit seems like too much of a gamble to me.

We should wait to lynch Ver. If later in the game, Ace and his source appear to be credible or Ver has some more evidence other than Ace's word stacked up against, we can lynch him, but in the light of the situation currently at hand, Ver's lynching does not benefit the town.
 
Old Post

 
 Camlito   Australia. December 15 2008 16:23. Posts 4036
Profile Blog # 

On December 15 2008 16:20 decafchicken wrote:
hahaha i just realized this thread got moved to sports n games
FAIL


Failing as usual already, decaf. Lol.

Can't wait for next set of clues to find a coffee clue and automatically kill you :D.
sAviOr...
Old Post

 
 Scaramanga   Australia. December 15 2008 16:25. Posts 7613
Profile Blog # 

On December 15 2008 16:23 Camlito wrote:

Show nested quote +



Failing as usual already, decaf. Lol.

Can't wait for next set of clues to find a coffee clue and automatically kill you :D.

LOL that was so bad, and nevake it looks like the votes are closed
Flash rapes and pillages your [s]expos[/s] villages | "If you are going on a trip, where would you like to go?"
Old Post

  Ver   United States. December 15 2008 16:26. Posts 1881Profile # 

On December 15 2008 16:01 Scaramanga wrote:

Show nested quote +



Sorry ver, heres how it goes, your gonna get lynched tonight and if you flip green/blue then i can vouch for ace and then we lynch the fake dt, we traded you for a mafia, the better situation is that you are mafia, then we have a hidden dt with someone to speak and we can set some shit up, anyhow your gonna get lynched first night


Show nested quote +



Its odd that right after we get a spot of good luck you come out of no where to help ver, you guys havent really helped each other so why are you comming out all of a sudden in defence?, i dont see whats wrong with this plan, we get either get 1 mafia and a dt with a mouthpeice or we get 1 mafia dead for 1 townie, i'll take either of these

if you want me to re screen im happy to do so

What i think is weird is that you tried previously to get people to continue to vote for me even though i have proved without a doubt that im a townie, then you come to attack a plan that gets us at least 1 mafia



Yes you proved yourself without a doubt with a PICTURE. I don't possibly understand how you, or anyone else can delude themselves into thinking that a picture of a pm proves that you are innocent. All that does is convince brainless townies, just as this did (shallow was mafia, dragoon townie).

http://img229.imageshack.us/img229/3694/sillymafiafj7.png

I'm not saying your guilty, as there are reasons for you posting that either as mafia or townie. But it sure is nowhere near proof of innocence.

Your picture is just as credible as you 'vouching' for Ace if I turn up innocent. Try better next time.

@ Camlito:

Yeah I agree that I am one of the important people to discover right away and this isn't some low probability event. However, I a) haven't posted a thing and b) the 'DT,' rather than checking the more active/better/important Ace, instead checks me and pms Ace on blind trust. You know how fishy that sounds?
Twitter- @VerInspired
Old Post

 
 BloodyC0bbler   Canada. December 15 2008 16:26. Posts 6661
Profile Blog # 
[image loading]


Night 1

As the town has spent the day fighting and bickering among itself, dragging people to and from the gallows, ever so close to flip the switch. When the sun was about to fall however they finally made up their mind, dragging Ver up, and putting the noose around his neck, he glares at them in contempt. The switch is flipped and Ver dies in dignity


All people with usable night actions send them in now.

Deadline will be 24 hours to start, if in 12 i have almost no actions in, i will extend it.
Last edit: 2008-12-15 16:32:21
#3 Member of the Chill Fanclub / Rhaegar fought nobly. Rhaegar fought valiantly. Rhaegar fought honorably. And Rhaeger died. --Ser Jorah Mormont TL MAFIA FORUM http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/index.php?show_part=31 go go !
Old Post

 
 Camlito   Australia. December 15 2008 16:26. Posts 4036
Profile Blog # 
Yes i see its pretty fishy isn't it? :D
sAviOr...
Old Post

 
 Scaramanga   Australia. December 15 2008 16:27. Posts 7613
Profile Blog # 
haha epic clutch dts = win
GOGO TOWN DIE VER MAFIA SCUM
Flash rapes and pillages your [s]expos[/s] villages | "If you are going on a trip, where would you like to go?"
Old Post

 
 chaoser   United States. December 15 2008 16:27. Posts 5538
Profile Blog # 

On December 15 2008 16:19 Camlito wrote:

Show nested quote +



If ver is actually mafia this bandwagon is justified. People can see something as good and agree with what ace found, it's not like they read the name of someone who posted and see "ACE" and just agree with him.



but in the future if people argue with ace, people will be more likely to trust ace. this game is all about power/trust balance and once mafia gains more trust than blue, we lose, simple as that. i'm afraid with people throwing trust around so easily (changing from target to target) that we are giving our trust away too easily and i just want to remind everyone to BE SUSPICIOUS!

and once again, ver being mafia does not justify ANYTHING. Sure, we got rid of a mafia, but they just gained our trust (which seems to be very easy to do apparently)

and thanks nevake, always nice that someone understands
Haven't you heard? I'm not an ex-progamer. I'm not a poker player. I'm not an admin of the site. I'm mother fucking Rekrul.
Old Post

 
 Camlito   Australia. December 15 2008 16:28. Posts 4036
Profile Blog # 
Chaoser i know what you mean . I've just been in enough mafia games now to see that argument over and over and it just seems repeditive, but i know what you mean. You are right, but the way i read your posts it seemed you wanted to aid the delaying of vers lynch.
sAviOr...
Old Post

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62
Please log in or register to reply.
 
Refresh
StarCraft: Brood War
StarCraft 2
Dota 2
[ Show 119 non-featured ]

» Recent SC2 Results
» Premier SC2 Tournaments
Sidebar Settings...

The Little App Factory



The opinions expressed by our users do not reflect the official position of TeamLiquid.net or its staff.

Advertising | Jobs | Privacy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren. Ad tag: TF_US.
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2002-2013 Teamliquid.net. All Rights Reserved