|
On June 15 2017 00:12 Tumblewood wrote: so far i'm thinking ruxxar and disfo have basically dumbtelled by taking sl's claim at fake value. unless i am actually operating on way less irony than them Don't think they are dumbtelled town for believing a claim. They are more likely town if SL is mafia.
or what do you mean?
|
Bleh. I am off for a while. Give TW some time to catch up.
|
|
On June 15 2017 00:14 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On June 15 2017 00:12 Tumblewood wrote: so far i'm thinking ruxxar and disfo have basically dumbtelled by taking sl's claim at fake value. unless i am actually operating on way less irony than them Don't think they are dumbtelled town for believing a claim. They are more likely town if SL is mafia. or what do you mean? believing the claim requires not realizing that sl just made that up. and if rux or disfo are mafia then they should figure that out because it doesn't reconcile at all with the information that they have. i think there's a corner case of this where they're mafia with eversince, but i figure they are still probably town. and if sl is mafia... idk, at least disfo is kinda scrubby and might take it as a legit fakeclaim
|
|
hmm i guess "i randomly generated [the check]" doesn't totally exclude the possibility of sl as a role that gets to check someone pregame. but that is like 2% chance territory so i won't worry about it too much
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
I take annul's side in annul vs koshi. It is weird to town read vivax for an annul read if he doesn't town read annul.
If he doesn't town read annul after reading vivax's post then he doesn't agree with it in which case it's not a good vivax post (but he says it is!) because it could absolutely be fabricated.
And then all the other town reads are superficial bull shit. And then I'm not even high up or flat null. Bs.
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
This isn't a themed game is it? Why would you assume there's bs roles?
|
i think he is talking about one of my posts where i was musing about sl's red check thing
|
On June 15 2017 00:24 disformation wrote: i think he is talking about one of my posts where i was musing about sl's red check thing that stuff:
On June 14 2017 18:32 disformation wrote: hmmm... cop with a random check at the start of the game? hmmmmmmmmm... like dunno. cop with a random green check at the start of the game doesnt sound too far fetched imo.
cop with a red at the very start of the game is really nasty for scum. esp. since pre game it was kinda implied that a lot of ppl wanted "weaker" and less swingy power roles. doesnt help that the check is on someone who has a history of not showing up or afking a bunch.
On June 14 2017 18:34 disformation wrote: in a themed game i would maybe believe a BH inspired power role, but i think this is supposed to be a large normal
|
Tw thought process is reading more town than scum for me currently.
As for that hf, eh I can kinda see it in some regards. I like vivax thought process a lot in that read. But I'm not convinced that annul is town by that read. If that makes sense.
In any regard I think this argument is stupid though meh.
|
Damdred is 100% town. This is my top read.
|
I'll read another filter later. But trust this read, I am telling it to you as a friend.
|
On June 15 2017 00:30 Palmar wrote: Damdred is 100% town. This is my top read.
Well hello there sexy
|
On June 15 2017 00:30 Palmar wrote: Damdred is 100% town. This is my top only read. fixed. =D
|
i dont mind that read though, so carry on. xD
|
For annuls point on Koshi you need to put the question in the room:
Can you still think that an argument is good without arriving to the same conclusion?
Yes -> It's a null point. No -> Koshi is mafia.
|
Vote Count - Day 1
Koshi (5): Holyflare, disformation, beentheredonethat, Vivax, annul raynpelikoneet (2): Xatalos, sicklucker Palmar (2): Koshi, Skynx Xatalos (1): darthfoley beentheredonethat (0): Koshi Eversince (0): sicklucker
Not voted (12): Palmar, Rels, Damdred, Tumblewood, VayneAuthority, raynpelikoneet, AMG, marvellosity, Grackaroni, Fecalfeast, ruXxar, Eversince
Half the Sky is getting ready to throw Koshi out of her whiskey bar. Day 1 ends in at 23:00 GMT (+00:00).
The voting thread is here and only votes in the voting thread will be counted.
|
I think Koshi's latest post streak speaks more for town Koshi than scum Koshi. I see the town spark in his game now.
##Unvote
Let's see if others arrive to the same conclusion on their own or want me to explain why I did.
|
Canada11355 Posts
On June 15 2017 00:12 Tumblewood wrote: so far i'm thinking ruxxar and disfo have basically dumbtelled by taking sl's claim at fake value. unless i am actually operating on way less irony than them I assume you mean face value but why can't scum see the fake cop claim and roll with it to gauge reactions?
[HR]
I don't like how ruxxar seems incapable of taking a joke. Makes me think he's trying too hard. + Show Spoiler +On June 14 2017 08:27 ruXxar wrote: What cred? he didn't understand damdred saying he would ride the cred of busing me and koshi and 'believed' sickluckers claim to the point where he said we should lynch ever and then sicklucker. The way he said it made me instantly think of a scum trying to set up 2 mislynches.
I don't like bdtds reads but that doesn't make him scum or town.
I like HF, disfo, vivax.
I had a point about someone speaking for someone else but I seem to have lost the tab. Phone posting at work sucks so I'm gonna work instead i guess
|
|
|
|