PowerRank - November - Page 3
Forum Index > SC2 General |
GhandiEAGLE
United States20754 Posts
| ||
S2Lunar
1051 Posts
He hasn't even been in GSTL for a long time. | ||
Jisall
United States2054 Posts
Stephano is major sick, but he seems to have fallen off recently. Idra is rediculously good, but hes getting tilted again. When his minds right i would put him up in the 6-8 region. My Powerrank: 1. Leenock 2. MVP 3. Naniwa 4. Jjakji 5. Oz 6. Huk 7. MMA 8. DRG 9. Nestea 10. Hero | ||
Ace.Xile
United States286 Posts
On November 28 2011 14:17 VirgilSC2 wrote: This is the reason you should leave Power Ranking to the people who analyze games on a professional level. Ret, for one, does not deserve to be on this list above players like PuMa or Stephano. MMA's results in November consisted of the Ro16 in GSL, and then quick losses from his seeded position at Providence. It seems like you completely threw the ASUS ROG tournament as well as the IPL 4 i44 Qualifiers and Battle in Berlin out the window as far as tournament results go. SuperNoVa should also be on this list above a few of the players listed, with his high finishes in both Korean WCG and AoL2. I don't get this, you criticize him for his choice on whos in, and then mention stephano who has done absolutely nothing in november, he lost to goody in battle in berlin, he didn't make it out of his group in dreamhack, and the only difficult person he even had to play in the uk qualifier was sase. Ugh ppl. Yeah he had a great october, but he hasn't really done anything this month in terms of success that would warrant him in top 10. | ||
iky43210
United States2099 Posts
| ||
HickleStine
Australia276 Posts
| ||
Elean
689 Posts
For instance if you only consider november, I really can't see why Nestea would be in top 10. You just gave him a spot because you like him. But I guess you clearly indicated you weren't serious when you placed Ret in the top 10. | ||
ElusoryX
Singapore2047 Posts
| ||
Crig
France18 Posts
| ||
Deleted User 61629
1664 Posts
| ||
winthrop
Hong Kong956 Posts
I would like to say that Naniwa's performance is much better than Hero. smelt some liquid bias. | ||
Mackguy
France40 Posts
I don't understand this ranking at all, is it based on tournament results ? Because many of them did not win anything in november... Is it based on how good you think they are at the moment ? because some of them did have a terrible month in november. in both cases, if you take into account the end of october tournament results, and what happend in november you have for example: 1. Stephano who won major tournaments in october, (IPL, ESWC), also won agaisnt Tails in the Finals of IPL uk qualifiers (10 000$), so yes he did not go to MLG, he was to busy winning in the uk. @DH yes, he lost to sheth and Naniwa, who both are currently playing so well. 2. Puma : DH finalists, took out so many good players Genius, DRG, only to narrowly lost in the finals to hero. His mlg run was quite good also : taking out Losira and bomber rank 6 to 10 : seems totally off, and bit random... These next few are really hard simply because after the top 5, I either haven’t seen enough of these players or just haven’t seen them hit the podium this month to get a good idea " we agree on that. | ||
KevinIX
United States2472 Posts
| ||
bittman
Australia8759 Posts
On November 28 2011 22:37 KevinIX wrote: Leenock can't be doubted anymore. Based on a good run? You're right! Stephano must have been #1 in the world for the week between IPL3 and the MLG after. Don't get me wrong, Leenock fan here, but MVP has not had one bad placing in the last few months. Leenock's just on a hot streak, so if he's "undoubtably" #1, then this isn't power rank november, but power rank November Week 3-4 or something? | ||
Laserist
Turkey4269 Posts
| ||
TheLOLas
United States646 Posts
| ||
DarkPlasmaBall
United States42211 Posts
Also, I would put Nestea below some of the others (just for this month). Here's mine: 1- Leenock 2- MVP 3- Hero 4- Naniwa 5/6- Oz and Jjakji (or reversed- no spoilers- based on who won last night ^^) 7- DRG (not "the Dong" though... that's Jaedong from BW >.<) 8- Nestea 9- MMA 10- Puma ::shrugs:: I like your write-ups though Nice job overall | ||
bqm
94 Posts
This is a Power rank for 1 month. Huk knocked out of code S ro16, lose MLG where his seed guarantee him a top 12, dream hack....?? maybe idra for his ASUS tournament Puma for the Dream Hack 2nd place Nestea dont make it this month in my opinion, I do not doubt MVP for top 2 he did so well in AoL2 and WCG korea, GSL ro4 and impressive run through open bracket in MLG just to lose to Leenock. Edit here is my rank, 1. Leenock 2. MVP 3. Hero 4. Naniwa 5.Jjakji 6. Oz 7. DongRaegu 8.Puma 9.MMA 10-15.Idra/ Ret/ Nerchio/ Nestea/ Sc/ MC/ Huk? | ||
Badfatpanda
United States9719 Posts
MMA similarly hasn't done all that much, I could see him maybe? at #10, but regardless I really believe PuMa should be in there, he had great run at both Providence and Dreamhack while Ret got a 3rd place finish. And Oz>DRG, I think this would be tons easier if you separated foreign/korean though | ||
Spectorials
558 Posts
- Came 2nd in Dreamhack. Beat DRG in Quarters who is in your top 10 (quite convincingly too). - Finished 6-1 in NASL only dropping 4 maps. - Got knocked out of MLG Providence late in the tournament by IdrA, however, the game before he got knocked out he 2-0'd Ret (your 10th place). Cmon... you must have just forgot him! | ||
| ||