|
On a reread
I dont mind gracks shit posting. I think it leans town to have wasted 1hr doing rhe bubvle t shitpost and then immediately spam about hf crumpets. Its very "in thr moment" having fun etc.
The two sticking out to me is chez and prplhz I couldnt care which is voted out first.
I wilk go with chez cos no reason in partocular.
##vote: chezinu
|
Fixed the deadline timer in all the counts in both threads. The deadline is 2300 BST/1800 EST. Apologies for any confusion.
|
Vivax last game he entered with vote and then nothing xcept ignoring me and make dumb posts about Kelsier.
Here he is way different.
Different and I think town.
|
Ok let's reread thread and count.
|
On September 27 2018 19:59 Mocsta wrote:Vivax, you raised a good point about koshi, that made me question the validity of my read. So I checked the last game, and I think the outcome (vig shot) has masked how it got there. Koshi voted HF after the first 24hrs, and proceed with this quote " Show nested quote +On September 08 2018 21:20 Koshi wrote: Lynch HF for being anti town on purpose. In this town we needed help. He didn't do that. So he plays super anti town.
If he flips town we got rid of a bad town and can be proud of ourselves. If he flips mafia I should get 3 virgins and a pet dragon.
Bonus: Sergio lasing out on HF was completely unnecessary and suggests a connection. " Like whether right or wrong, I can see a connection with the shot and meh.. I want a pet dragon.
|
On September 27 2018 22:07 Mocsta wrote: i played a 5p mini before and rolled scum or jester. cant remember much other than that it was REALLY hard to initiate conversation. So little player count makes it much easier to scrutinise posts etc.
I think its quite reasonable that in a 9p game, that there is a similar trepidation.
This is what pinged me to originalname.
He is clearly coherent and well-versed in the mechanics of the game; yet is content plodding along and only sharing that wealth of knowledge when prodded. The thing is, whilst logically sound, it is merely an encyclopedic reference, as opposed to insight for *THIS* game. I may as well be connected to an AI chatbot....
For me, this is the strongest correlation to scum comfort/mentality I have seen all game, which is why my vote was placed.
I will not be around between now and deadline. Good luck imo decent post + reasoning to lynch somebody.
|
On September 27 2018 22:13 OriginalName wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2018 21:44 Conversion wrote:On September 27 2018 07:17 OriginalName wrote:On September 27 2018 07:08 Mocsta wrote: TL is dead.. like.. why even join if you not going to play. Why does this discussion keep coming up.. seriously..
we already know that lynching an afk'r is a terrible option.
(1) there is limited to nil content to vote analyse (2) if we hit town, we are essentially at d1 again (3) as proven recently by HF, it can create seeds of distrust in town that never disappear. (4) The rules require 3 posts per cycle. 2nd offense is modkill. So AFK will self-resolve if genuine; and if making 1 post to stay alive, then we can sort that out as required. and lastly, (4) if the lottery pick actually hits, we are unlikely to be closer to finding the other mafia; given the ease for either alignment to bandwagon.
I would rather "no-lynch" vote then throw a random afk.
I can't get over that in a 9 player game, the activity is so poor that 1/3 is contemplating a random afk vote. I mean I'd rather no Lynch too but this is plurality. The reason the disscussion probably comes up time and time again is that at least some people try to post meaningfully, there's no reason we have to commit to it yet but theres no reason that we can't contemplate it. and even with these points I'd say 3 and 4 are probably the two most valid ones. point 1 is only bad if literally its 'agree to afk lynch and then do it and everyone shuts up afterwords' point 2 is negated by lack of a no lynch option, since low activity d1 lynches are basically just as random as an afk lynch imo. hell if you want a no lynch option your not going to get better than lynching a modkillee since its essentially the same thing. I don’t like this post and I don’t like how hard you are pushing into lynching an AFK question is, do you also like taro boba? I don't think I'm pushing that hard into afk lynching at all considering I stated multiple times that if a better option presented itself I'd prefer that. I also don't think Mocsta is scum just for voting me over a difference of opinion and I'm honestly confused why he went all "IF ITS BETWEEN ME AND ON IM GOING TO VOTE ON!!!!" when honestly I think both of us are pretty piss poor options since at least we were trying have some posts with actual substance. Holyflare and Conversion both arguing over minor semantics like 'how green should your reads start' literally just reads like posting for the sake of posting to me. Which I mean is better than just lurking but considering that honestly it shouldn't matter how people read as long as you're willing to be objective and actually be willing to change your reads. and like cool now everyones posted, tbh i think its weird that chezinu just quickly hops on the first wagon presented and I'd like to know why he did that. I haven't exactly been around for more than a few years and I'm not trawling 5-6 games to metagame you guys so I'm just saying how it looks to me without past context. Good defense. But that is what it is. A defense.
Would be better if the good observation made here was on the attack.
Why are you smart while defending and mediocre on the attack?
bad on.
|
That being said. Chez should be the lynch indeed lol.
|
Holyflare I Mocsta II Conversion II
These people made jabby posts that I liked for jabbyness. They are ok for now.
I think Conversion and Mocsta are even townreads.
|
Mocsta Conversion Holyflare prplhz Grackaroni OriginalName Vivax Chezinu
I think this is my list.
|
The main reason Chez is so low is because it feels like he is pretending to do things.
On September 27 2018 12:40 Chezinu wrote: Koshi, Conversion, and OrignalName
What do yall think about Grackaroni, Holyflare, and Mocsta?
And this is also horrible.
On September 27 2018 12:35 Chezinu wrote: plurality .. ugh.. and he knew about it. ON the ON Train!
|
Oh he even voted ON...
I don't know. I also don't like ON but I have no clue what Chez is doing and it doesnt feel good.
Mafia tries to avoid being this obvious mafia so I don't know tbh. I don't know if Chez is this obvious as mafia.
|
Mafia!Chez played bad. Mafia!ON is playing smart.
Town!Chez is being random Town!ON is playing reactive and holding information from the thread
|
|
I am voting supershitter Vivax
##unvote ##vote Vivax
|
I can see a world in which town!Chez is just doing things and that look bad without him realizing it.
|
Well I am going to eat @ my dads but I will be back. Also probably will be checking phone.
|
Vivax and Chez why shouldn't we hang either of you.
|
Wait, does Koshi want to lynch Vivax or no?
On September 28 2018 00:26 Koshi wrote: Vivax last game he entered with vote and then nothing xcept ignoring me and make dumb posts about Kelsier.
Here he is way different.
Different and I think town.
You think he is town or what?
|
I think Vivax may be an lynch, he looks pretty different from last game in that he is very much less active. However, in both this game and in the last game he started out by arguing against thread sentiment, last game against the Kaley-scum-read and this game against the Koshi-town-read. He seems sort of fit for fight so mostly I think he looks scummy because he's not as active as I think he almost always are.
|
|
|
|